Fight escalates over plan to keep Asian carp out of the Great Lakes

Dec 17, 2010 By Dan Egan

The Obama administration on Thursday released its 2011 battle plan in the ongoing fight to keep Asian carp from invading the Great Lakes, a plan that calls for no waterway closures in the Chicago area. Less than three hours later, Michigan Attorney General Mike Cox announced plans to push ahead with a court fight to order the waterways closed.

Earlier this month, federal Judge Robert Dow Jr. denied a request for a preliminary injunction by Michigan, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Ohio and Pennsylvania to close two navigation locks in Chicago as an emergency, stopgap measure to block the carp.

The judge did not rule on the larger request by the states to force the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to move ahead with plans to build a permanent barrier on the canal system to re-create the natural separation between Lake Michigan and the Mississippi basin that the Chicago canals destroyed over a century ago.

Cox said the five-state coalition is pressing ahead with its case to permanently separate the basins, but in the meantime the states are going to take their case to close the locks to the 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.

"Although our suit continues to move forward, the urgent threat that pose requires that we aggressively pursue this preliminary injunction," Cox said in a statement. "Until the federal government takes effective action, Michigan and our Great Lakes partners will take full advantage of every opportunity we have to ensure our livelihood is not destroyed by Asian carp."

It will be Cox's fourth attempt this year to get the courts to close the locks; the U.S. Supreme Court twice denied the request before Dow declined it on Dec. 2.

Business groups and many political leaders in Illinois fiercely opposed the idea of closing the locks because of the effect it could have on barge traffic, recreational boats, barge-dependent industries and floodwater management in the Chicago area.

In Washington, D.C., meanwhile, the Obama administration released its "Asian Carp Control Strategy Framework," a 63-page document put together by 21 state and federal agencies that calls for increased "environmental" DNA testing for Asian carp in the Chicago canal system, more assessments of the effectiveness of an electric barrier system and a plan to develop new carp traps and nets, among other things.

"The Obama administration has taken an aggressive, unprecedented approach to protect our Great Lakes and the communities and economies that depend on them from the Asian carp," John Goss, Asian carp director for the Whitehouse Council on Environmental Quality, said in a news release.

Conservationists weren't wowed. They've been critical of the Obama's administration's slow progress toward what they see as the only real solution to the problem - physically plugging the canals with permanent barriers.

"The 'plan' remains an unintegrated menu of disconnected potential actions, random activities, and no sense of what will be done with new evidence of carp on emergency or long-term basis," said Henry Henderson of the Natural Resources Defense Council. "There is no articulated strategy, no sense of urgency, no apparent commitment to use the best tools such as (environmental) DNA to focus immediate action and build toward a permanent solution."

The industry group Unlock our Jobs expressed gratitude that the 2011 plan doesn't call for closure of any waterways, but it called the continued use of environmental DNA to track the fish "quite troubling."

Water samples taken above the electric barrier in the past year have yielded evidence of Asian carp all over the Chicago metropolitan area, but industry groups have questioned whether a positive sample means a live fish is in the area.

"It (environmental DNA sampling) has not been peer-tested and - even further - has been seriously questioned by many in the scientific community," said Mark Biel, chairman of UnLock Our Jobs.

Caught in the middle of the fight over how to deal with one of the most vexing environmental and economic problems to face the in modern times is Goss, whom many in the media have dubbed the "carp czar."

In an interview Wednesday, Goss noted that it is his job to keep the carp from getting into the lakes, but he acknowledged that responsibility comes with no real authority to take action.

"It's my job to coordinate the resources to stop the fish, that's accurate," he said. "I don't have full authority to order any actions."

When asked who will be held accountable if the federal efforts fail to keep the fish from invading, Goss paused for nine seconds before answering: "Well . . . Congress hasn't given that job to anybody, that I know of."

Explore further: Rare south-west fish suffers further decline


Related Stories

Wildlife officials search for carp in Chicago area

Feb 17, 2010

(AP) -- Armed with sprawling fishing nets and boats equipped with electric prods, state and federal fisheries biologists began a "search-and-destroy" mission in Chicago-area waterways Wednesday aimed at rooting out the dreaded ...

Judge focuses on carp DNA in lawsuit over locks

Oct 18, 2010

(AP) -- The reliability of DNA testing suggesting Asian carp may already be in waterways near Lake Michigan was the focus of final arguments Monday in a lawsuit seeking the closure of Chicago-area shipping locks to halt ...

Asian carp found close to Lake Michigan, past barriers

Jun 24, 2010

A 19-pound Asian carp has been found near the shore of Lake Michigan, above a navigation lock that regional political leaders had been demanding the Army Corps slam shut to try to keep the invaders out of the world's largest ...

Recommended for you

Keeping hungry jumbos at bay

13 hours ago

Until now electric fences and trenches have proved to be the most effective way of protecting farms and villages from night time raids by hungry elephants. But researchers think they may have come up with ...

Rare south-west fish suffers further decline

17 hours ago

Researchers have discovered that the range of one of Western Australia's rarest freshwater fishes, Balston's Pygmy Perch, could have declined by as much as 25 per cent.

Zoologists tap into GPS to track badger movements

18 hours ago

Zoologists from Trinity College Dublin's School of Natural Sciences are using GPS tracking technology to keep a 'Big Brother' eye on badgers in County Wicklow. By better understanding the badgers' movements and the reasons ...

Climate change costing soybean farmers

Mar 30, 2015

Even during a good year, soybean farmers nationwide are, in essence, taking a loss. That's because changes in weather patterns have been eating into their profits and taking quite a bite: $11 billion over ...

User comments : 11

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Dec 17, 2010
Once you've seen them, it is too late. It is time for DNA specific extermination. Hmm! I certain that no one is working on that science.
1 / 5 (2) Dec 17, 2010
I have an idea on how to deal with them that will simultaneously prevent things like this from happening in the future.

We take all the importers of animals, cut them into little pieces and have a fishing contest. The contest goes on until they are all caught and the person with the most gets a billion dollars. A prize like that will have the lakes full of fisherman and it would be cheaper than what invasive species cost us.

" to deal with one of the most vexing environmental and economic problems to face the Great Lakes in modern times..."

Deal with it? We aren't dealing with it nor are we dealing with the cause. Some scumbag is probably importing the next invasive species right now.
3 / 5 (2) Dec 18, 2010
The best revenge/cure is to eat them, mussels, fish, or whatever. How long did it take to eat sharks onto the endangered species list?

Invasive species are merely your name for Darwin's soldiers, fitter and better adapted for the changing world.
1 / 5 (1) Dec 18, 2010
Just to be a devil's advocate: Who is to say that as the negative press keep heaping on "Asian carps", some asians hot heads will not be pissed off and deliberately release them all over the place, to revenge for a perceived racist slur of a perfectly edible, choice fish in many parts of the world?
1 / 5 (1) Dec 18, 2010
I guess from the ratings of my post that there are at least 2 people here who like the fact the the US spends over $100 BILLION a year on invasive species. Are you stupid or enemies of the US?
3 / 5 (2) Dec 18, 2010
Or are the ten thousand Islamists with Bic Lighters camping in our national forests really terrorists or merely ravers?
3 / 5 (2) Dec 18, 2010
This is an easy problem to solve. Allow the unrestrictive fishing of Asian carp. Sell Asian carp fishing licenses for $10. Teach the fishermen what the carp looks like. Then buy the carp for 15 cents a pound. Take the carp and make feed out of them. No government involvement. No cost to tax payers. No more carp after a few years. Private enterprise comes to the rescue again.
1 / 5 (1) Dec 18, 2010
What are you skepticus, Taliban or stupid (not that there's any difference)? You are evidently happy that we and the rest of the world waste so much of our money on invasive species considering your ratings.

Or maybe you're dumb enough to think that ratings mean something? Do you think people filter out low rated posts? Anyone with a brain and that has been here a while knows that the ratings mean nothing because of people like you.
1 / 5 (1) Dec 18, 2010
What are you skepticus, Taliban or stupid (not that there's any difference)? You are evidently happy that we and the rest of the world waste so much of our money on invasive species considering your ratings.

Or maybe you're dumb enough to think that ratings mean something? Do you think people filter out low rated posts? Anyone with a brain and that has been here a while knows that the ratings mean nothing because of people like you.

I don't care one jot about the ratings people gave me. I just speak my mind. If it satisfy you or others slamming "taliban", "stupid", or whatever hat you guys invent on my head, go right ahead! It's just reinforces the hypocrisy of free speech and all the other bullshit your holier-than-thou breed trying to impose on others. What's that different from the Islamic nutjobs trying to cram their worldviews down every "infidel" throat? Go to your church this Sunday, "confess your sins", and repeat with what you've been doing for the rest of the week
not rated yet Dec 19, 2010

Merry Christmas.
1 / 5 (1) Dec 21, 2010

Merry Christmas.

Merry Christmas to you too.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.