Elective single embryo transfer boosts the chance of a healthy baby

Dec 22, 2010 By Jennifer Phillips

Women who undergo elective single embryo transfer as part of in-vitro fertlisation (IVF) are five times more likely to give birth to a healthy baby compared with double embryo transfer, finds a new study published on bmj.com today.

The study recommends that clinicians should, from now on, advise women to have an elective single (eSET) as part of treatment rather than a double embryo transfer (DET).

Although there has been increasing success in treatments in recent years, there have also been growing concerns about rising rates of multiple pregnancies, which are associated with increased maternal and perinatal illness and death, as well as increased costs to the health service.

A previous review of studies comparing data on eSET versus DET concluded that, although eSET reduced the odds of , it halved the odds of per fresh cycle of treatment.

However, there has been, until now, a lack of evidence about the effect of single versus double embryo transfer in different groups of women and on outcomes such as miscarriage, and low birth weight.

So an international team of researchers, led by the University of Aberdeen, studied data on 1,367 women from eight eligible trials. A total of 683 and 684 women were randomised to the eSET and DET groups for this analysis.

This showed that in 27% (181 out of 683) of women who underwent a fresh IVF cycle using a single embryo transfer, they gave birth to a healthy baby, compared with 42% (285 out of 683) of women who had a healthy baby following double embryo transfer.

However, the gap between the two types of embryo transfer leading to successful births was much closer when an additional frozen single embryo was transferred at a later date following the first eSET - resulting in a 38% successful birth rate, compared with a 42% birth rate in double embryo transfer cases.

Results showed that the chances of a full-term single birth (over 37 weeks) following single embryo transfer were almost five times higher than those following double embryo transfer.

Single embryo transfer was also seen to reduce the risk of premature births — pregnant women were 87% more likely to avoid a premature birth before 37 weeks, having had a single embryo transfer.

The chance of delivering a baby with for single embryo transfer cases was a third of the chance for double embryo transfer cases.

Although adopting a strategy of always giving a single embryo transfer yielded a lower pregnancy rate than giving them double embryo transfer in a fresh IVF cycle, the difference was almost completely overcome by an additional frozen single embryo transfer cycle.

The researchers conclude: “Our review should be useful in informing decision making regarding the number of to transfer in IVF. Given the opportunity for replacing a single frozen thawed embryo in a subsequent cycle, elective single embryo transfer should thus be the default position.”

In an accompanying editorial, Allan Templeton, Professor of Obstetrics and Gynaecology at the University of Aberdeen asks: why have we not adopted this approach in the UK? He argues that in a commercially competitive environment, “clinicians have been distracted by success rates and do not see the more important healthy outcomes.”

He concludes: “At a time when the beginning of assisted reproduction is being recognized as an outstanding contribution to medical science, practitioners have a responsibility to develop its use wisely. Doctors managing infertile couples are no longer entitled to take risks with the health of the next generation.”

Explore further: Secret of tetanus toxicity offers new way to treat motor neuron disease

More information: Click here to view paper: www.bmj.com/cgi/doi/10.1136/bmj.c6945

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Single embryo implants work better: study

Mar 25, 2009

Implanting single embryos into the wombs of women seeking to boost fertility is more effective and less costly than placing two embryos at a time, a pair of studies released Wednesday found.

New strategy could reduce twin rate after IVF

Sep 30, 2010

A strategy to encourage single embryo transfer after in vitro fertilisation (IVF) could be an important tool to prevent multiple pregnancies and their associated complications, finds a study published in the British Medical ...

3 IVF attempts double chances

Nov 09, 2009

Just one in three women gives birth after a single IVF attempt, but the cumulative chance of a live birth increases with each cycle - where women are offered three cycles nearly two thirds go on to have babies, reveals a ...

Recommended for you

Stroke damage mechanism identified

Nov 27, 2014

Researchers have discovered a mechanism linked to the brain damage often suffered by stroke victims—and are now searching for drugs to block it.

User comments : 0

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.