Studies: Drug, device help treat heart failure

Nov 14, 2010 By MARILYNN MARCHIONE , AP Medical Writer

(AP) -- Millions of people with mild or moderate heart failure got good news Sunday, with studies showing a Pfizer drug and a device from Medtronic can boost survival and cut trips to the hospital by patients having trouble breathing.

But another drug that's been used for nearly a decade - Johnson & Johnson's Natrecor - did little to help those with severe heart failure in a big study aimed at settling whether the drug raised the risk of death or kidney problems.

"They resolved the safety issue but in the meantime showed it was not very effective," and it's hard to tell now which patients should get the pricey medicine, said Dr. Alfred Bove, a Temple University heart specialist and past president of the American College of Cardiology.

All three studies were presented Sunday at an American Heart Association conference in Chicago and are expected to have an immediate effect on care.

More than 5 million Americans and 22 million people worldwide have heart failure. It develops when the heart muscle weakens over time and can no longer pump effectively, often because of damage from a heart attack. Fluid can back up into the lungs and leave people gasping for breath.

Inspra, made by New York-based Pfizer Inc., helps block water retention and is already used for advanced heart failure. In a study of more than 2,700 people with milder symptoms, it cut the risk of death or hospitalization by 37 percent. After nearly two years, less than 13 percent of those on Inspra had died of heart problems versus less than 16 percent of those given dummy pills.

Only 19 people would need to be treated for a year to prevent one heart failure hospitalization, and 51 to prevent one death, said the study's leader, Dr. Faiez Zannad of Nancy University in Nancy, France.

"This has the potential of changing the guidelines," said Dr. Mariell Jessup, who heads the conference and the heart failure program at the University of Pennsylvania.

Many doctors saw an alternative: wider use of an older relative of Inspra, spironolactone, a generic medicine that costs less than 20 cents a day, versus about $133 a month for Inspra.

Trying the older drug first and reserving Inspra for the few who suffer bad side effects is "a reasonable tactic," Dr. Paul Armstrong of the University of Alberta in Edmonton, Canada, wrote in an editorial published online with the study by the New England Journal of Medicine.

The other good news came from a test of an implanted heart device made by Minneapolis-based Medtronic Inc. Many people with severe heart failure already have defibrillators to zap their hearts if they suffer a rhythm problem. Newer combination devices also control how blood moves through the heart, improving pumping capacity.

"It's all electronics. You can almost build in an alarm clock and a Bluetooth device. You can put anything in those little boxes," but the issue is whether that is worth the extra cost, Bove said. Defibrillators cost $20,000 to $25,000; the combos are $5,000 to $7,000 more.

The study tested them in 1,800 Canadian patients with mild to moderate heart failure. More than three years later, 40 percent of those with simple defibrillators had died or been hospitalized for heart failure versus 33 percent of those with combo devices, said Dr. Anthony Tang of the University of Ottawa in Ontario, Canada.

Medtronic and the Canadian Institutes of Health Research paid for the study, and results were published online by the New England Journal of Medicine.

The bad news came from a test of Natrecor, a drug that had meteoric sales after its approval in 2001 because it was the only medicine that seemed to help shortness of breath. One out of every six people hospitalized with heart failure were given Natrecor until it came under a cloud in 2005 when studies suggested it raised the risk of death and kidney problems.

An independent panel recommended that its maker - Scios Inc., a division of New Brunswick, N.J.-based Johnson & Johnson - do a large study to resolve the issue.

In tests involving more than 7,000 patients in 30 countries, Natrecor made no difference in rates of hospitalization or death in the following month and only modestly relieved shortness of breath within 6 hours of its infusion, said Drs. Robert Califf and Adrian Hernandez, Duke University cardiologists who led the study.

Natrecor costs $500 to $700 plus infusion costs, Jessup said. If the drug "makes people feel better faster but doesn't impact outcomes, I'm not sure what the role is," she said.

Natrecor still had $66 million in annual sales in the United States last year, according to IMS Health, a healthcare information company.

Explore further: Recombinant peptide for transplantation of pancreatic islets in mice models of diabetes

More information:
Heart failure information:



Related Stories

Artificial heart implants approved in U.S.

Sep 06, 2006

The use of fully implanted artificial hearts for patients with advanced heart failure was approved for use Wednesday by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration.

Synchronizing a failing heart

Nov 14, 2010

November 14, 2010 – One of the largest, most extensive worldwide investigations into heart failure, led by the University of Ottawa Heart Institute (UOHI), conclusively proves that a new therapeutic implant synchronizes ...

New heart failure device is tested

Oct 17, 2006

Physicians at 50 U.S. medical facilities are taking part in a multinational clinical trial of a device designed to help heart failure victims.

Study: Heart failure drug guidelines often ignored

Oct 20, 2009

(AP) -- Most hospitalized heart failure patients are sent home without widely recommended inexpensive pills, despite a program to get more doctors to follow treatment guidelines, a study suggests.

Heart pumps save lives

Jun 14, 2010

Heart failure is a very common condition: around 200,000 people in Sweden have been diagnosed with the disease. Some patients with life-threatening heart failure can be helped by mechanical heart pumps, reveals a thesis from ...

Recommended for you

'Google Maps' for the body: A biomedical revolution

2 hours ago

A world-first UNSW collaboration that uses previously top-secret technology to zoom through the human body down to the level of a single cell could be a game-changer for medicine, an international research ...

New compounds could offer therapy for multitude of diseases

4 hours ago

An international team of more than 18 research groups has demonstrated that the compounds they developed can safely prevent harmful protein aggregation in preliminary tests using animals. The findings raise hope that a new ...

Novel nanoparticle therapy promotes wound healing

Mar 26, 2015

An experimental therapy developed by researchers at Albert Einstein College of Medicine of Yeshiva University cut in half the time it takes to heal wounds compared to no treatment at all. Details of the therapy, ...

User comments : 0

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.