Scientists find sign cave dwellers took care of elderly

October 11, 2010

Workers carry out an excavation at the Atapuerca archaeology site in July

Enlarge

Workers carry out an excavation at the Atapuerca archaeology site in July 2010. Scientists said Monday they had uncovered evidence suggesting cave dwellers who lived in northern Spain some 500,000 years ago took care of their elderly and infirm.

Scientists said Monday they had uncovered evidence suggesting cave dwellers who lived in northern Spain some 500,000 years ago took care of their elderly and infirm.

University of Madrid palaeontologists discovered the partial skeleton of a male of a European species ancestral to the who suffered from a stoop and possibly needed a stick to remain upright, they said in a statement.

"This individual would be probably impaired for hunting, among other activities. His survival during a considerable period with these impairments allows us to hypothesize that the nomadic group of which this individual was part would provide special care to aged individuals," it said.

The remains suggested the cave dweller died when he was over 45. They were found at Atapuerca in northern Spain's Burgos province, the site of several containing evidence of prehistoric human occupation.

The results of the study have been accepted for publication in the online edition of the of the United States, the scientists said.

An earlier study carried out at the same site in 2009 concluded that the cave dwellers who lived there were cannibals who valued the flesh of children and .

In 1994, palaeontologists also unearthed at Atapuerca the fossilised remains of Homo antecessor, or "Pioneer Man", believed to date back 800,000 years.

(c) 2010 AFP

Filter


Move the slider to adjust rank threshold, so that you can hide some of the comments.


Display comments: newest first

StillWind
Oct 11, 2010

Rank: 3 / 5 (2)
Does anyone else find it absurd that these people would provide care for their elderly, yet practice cannibalism of their young?
While there may be evidence of canibalism of the young, where is the evidence that it was "these" people who practiced cannibalism?
I have yet to see anything that makes this clear, and as such is just another example of the limited thinking of those responsible for making the claims.
MorituriMax
Oct 11, 2010

Rank: not rated yet
Sure they would. What better supply of ready-made jerky would they have been able to cultivate easier?
Mischa
Oct 11, 2010

Rank: 5 / 5 (1)
Does anyone else find it absurd that these people would provide care for their elderly, yet practice cannibalism of their young?
While there may be evidence of canibalism of the young, where is the evidence that it was "these" people who practiced cannibalism?
I have yet to see anything that makes this clear, and as such is just another example of the limited thinking of those responsible for making the claims.


This was the exact same thought I had when I read this article. There was two research projects, one this year about these cave dwellers caring for their elderly, and last year in 2009 when they found evidence of cannibalism. Are we sure that these are the same group of cave dwellers or is it two different groups of cave dwellers from different time periods? Those writing these articles should be more specific.
scidog
Oct 12, 2010

Rank: not rated yet
well even if they were the same group it makes sense to me.keep the old guy going who knows how to make fire and tools and all that survival stuff,plus he talks to the gods and eat the worthless kids who can't hunt and so on.maybe every winter was a Donner Pass for these people and when the young and weak went down they were food to keep the rest of the family alive.and if you want detail don't look here for it,this is just a news blog to direct you to the real research papers,which of course you would need a degree of some sort to really understand.
MarkyMark
Oct 12, 2010

Rank: not rated yet
To those who are confused [rightly] over the elderly care and canabalism of there [asunption] adolescents and children could likely find there answer in social ideals found in primitive tribal and clan societies where the old are often venerated as wisemen leaders and of course spirituall leaders.

Of course we can only guess what tribes were like back them and as a result many questions will never be answered.
kevinrtrs
Oct 12, 2010

Rank: 1 / 5 (5)
One has to question these "historic" dates that are so glibly proffered. How do they know it was 500k or 800k year ago? I know people will throw all kinds of dating methods at me but the question is still there: What methods did they use to date these findings and just how valid are they in this situation?
Did they at least do a C-14 carbon dating on the old bones to see if it contained any C-14?
Skeptic_Heretic
Oct 12, 2010

Rank: 5 / 5 (5)
Kev, they use multiple methods in order to determine the date. If you use only one method, your answer isn't necessarily valid as mistakes can be made, samples can be corrupted, etc.

When one announces a date they use multiple disparate forms of dating to come to an answer that agrees with multiple methods of determination.

Do you assume your stove is hot because someone else said it was or do you look for the surface heating indicator light, the presence of warmer air, the visual disturbance of heatwaves, or do you just never, ever touch your stove ever again?

Stop being so fantastically stupid.
Mischa
Oct 12, 2010

Rank: not rated yet
Thank you Scidog. I suppose writing a few extra words to clarify things is asking too much? Like saying, "An earlier study carried out at the same site in 2009 concluded that the [same group of] cave dwellers who lived there were [also] cannibals who valued the flesh of children and adolescents." Yes, I can read the research papers, but considering I already have so much to read, it would be helpful for a new article to give a better synopsis of those research papers. In this case, if they are going to mention an earlier research project, to be more clear about it. That was the point, with all due respect, that Stillwind and I was trying to make.
Rank 5 /5 (9 votes)
Relevant PhysicsForums posts

More news stories

Dinosaur with tiny arms unearthed in Argentina

Argentine experts have discovered the near-complete remains of a new species of Jurassic-era dinosaur that stood on its rear legs and had tiny arms, according to a leading paleontologist.

Other Sciences / Archaeology & Fossils

created 2 hours ago | popularity 5 / 5 (1) | comments 0

Social welfare cuts ultimately come with heavy price, researchers say

(Phys.org) -- Slashing government funding for Medicaid, food stamps and other programs that serve the poor – while politically popular with some lawmakers and many conservatives – may do more harm ...

Other Sciences / Social Sciences

created 22 hours ago | popularity 4.5 / 5 (8) | comments 69

Relatively speaking: Researchers identify principles that shape kinship categories across languages

Different languages refer to family relationships in different ways. For example, English speakers use two terms — grandmother and grandfather — to refer to grandparents, while Mandarin Chinese uses four terms. ...

Other Sciences / Social Sciences

created 15 hours ago | popularity 4 / 5 (4) | comments 0 | with audio podcast

Oldest art even older

New dates from Geißenklösterle Cave in Southwest Germany document the early arrival of modern humans and early appearance of art and music.

Other Sciences / Archaeology & Fossils

created 10 hours ago | popularity 5 / 5 (2) | comments 1

Psychologists examine how race affects juvenile sentencing

When it comes to holding children accountable for crimes they commit, race matters.

Other Sciences / Social Sciences

created 13 hours ago | popularity 3 / 5 (2) | comments 1


Computers excel at identifying smiles of frustration (w/ Video)

(Phys.org) -- Researchers at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) in the US have trained computers to recognize smiles, and they have turned out to be more adept at recognizing smiles of frustration ...

Is a classical electrodynamics law incompatible with special relativity?

(Phys.org) -- The laws of classical electromagnetism that were developed in the 19th century are the same laws that scientists use today. They include Maxwell’s four equations along with the Lorentz la ...

Solar plane ends first leg of intercontinental bid

The Swiss sun-powered aircraft Solar Impulse landed safely in Madrid early Friday at the end of the first leg of its attempt at an intercontinental flight without using a drop of fuel.

HyperSolar shows dirty water no barrier to power world

(Phys.org) -- The Santa Barbara, California, company, HyperSolar, is set to transparently share the ups and downs of its research experiences toward the company’s ultimate vision, successfully producing ...

Organic carbon from Mars, but not biological

(Phys.org) -- Molecules containing large chains of carbon and hydrogen--the building blocks of all life on Earth--have been the targets of missions to Mars from Viking to the present day. While these molecules ...

In nanorod crystal growth, nanoparticles seen as artificial atoms

In the growth of crystals, do nanoparticles act as "artificial atoms" forming molecular-type building blocks that can assemble into complex structures? This is the contention of a major but controversial theory ...