Studies: Pneumonia is misdiagnosed on patient readmissions

Oct 22, 2010

Patients were misdiagnosed with pneumonia at an alarming rate when they were readmitted to the hospital shortly after a previous hospitalization for the same illness, according to two Henry Ford Hospital companion studies.

Researchers say the misdiagnoses led to overuse of antibiotics and increased . Pneumonia ranks second to congestive as the reason for readmission within 30 days of a previous hospitalization.

Led by Henry Ford Infectious Diseases physicians Hiren Pokharna, M.D., and Norman Markowitz, M.D., researchers found that:

  • 72 percent of patients were misdiagnosed with pneumonia upon readmission to the same hospital.
  • African-Americans were twice more likely than Caucasians to be misdiagnosed with pneumonia.
  • Patients who smoke or have lung disease were likely to be misdiagnosed with pneumonia.
  • 72 percent of the misdiagnoses occurred in the Emergency Department.
  • Fewer than 33 percent of patients had any outpatient follow-up care prior to their readmission.
Results of the two companion studies will be presented Friday at the 48th annual meeting of the Society of America Oct. 21-24 in Vancouver.

"These studies show that we need to increase awareness among physicians about using the diagnostic standards and criteria set forth in the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's National Healthcare Safety Network for diagnosing pneumonia at the time of readmission," says Dr. Pokharna, a fellow at Henry Ford and the lead author of the companion studies.

"This also points to the importance of using X-ray for ruling out pneumonia. And once pneumonia is ruled out, the antibiotics can be discontinued."

In seeking to explain the difficulty of diagnosing pneumonia and high prevalence of misdiagnoses, Henry Ford researchers examined medical records of 127 patients diagnosed with pneumonia between December 2008 and December 2009 and readmitted within 30 days of a previous hospitalization.

Researchers found that 92 of the 127 patients were misdiagnosed with health care associated pneumonia using CDC/National Healthcare Safety Network criteria. Health care associated pneumonia is a newly recognized form of in patients who had recent close contact with a health care system, either through a hospital, outpatient dialysis center, nursing home or long-term care facility. The classification was added with the shift from hospital-based care to home-based care.

Researchers cited several reasons for the misdiagnoses, including pre-existing lung disease and abnormalities on chest X-rays.

Explore further: West African airline suspends flights amid Ebola (Update)

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Lower-cost hospital care is not always lower in quality

Feb 22, 2010

The costs that hospitals incur in treating patients vary widely and do not appear to be strongly associated either with the quality of care patients receive or their risk of dying within 30 days, according to a report in ...

Flu vaccine may not protect seniors well

Aug 01, 2008

A Group Health study in the August 2 issue of The Lancet adds fuel to the growing controversy over how well the flu vaccine protects the elderly.

Statins associated with lower risk of death from pneumonia

Oct 27, 2008

Individuals who take cholesterol-lowering statins before being hospitalized with pneumonia appear less likely to die within 90 days afterward, according to a report in the October 27 issue of Archives of Internal Medicine, one of ...

Recommended for you

Reducing kidney injury using a quality improvement method

56 minutes ago

Using quality improvement measures in eight of the 10 hospitals in the Northern New England Cardiovascular Disease Study Group, researchers have found a way to reduce kidney injury in patients undergoing a procedure with ...

App for headache sufferers shows success

13 hours ago

A unique app that helps headache sufferers to record the severity and regularity of their pain is being used as part of a Griffith research study.

West African airline suspends flights amid Ebola (Update)

18 hours ago

(AP)—Police officers deployed to Liberia's international airport to ensure passengers are screened for Ebola symptoms as a major regional airline announced Tuesday it was suspending flights to the cities hardest hit by ...

User comments : 0