One in four military applicants denied due to obesity

Oct 15, 2010 By Ted Boscia

At a time when American military forces are stretched thin overseas, a growing number of potential recruits are too fat to enlist, according to an analysis by Cornell economists.

In the past half-century, the number of women of age who exceed the U.S. Army's enlistment standards for weight-for-height and body fat percentage has more than tripled. For military-age men, the figure has more than doubled. As of 2007-08, 5.7 million men, or nearly 12 percent, and 16.5 million women, about 35 percent, of military age are ineligible for duty because they are overweight or obese, estimate John Cawley, associate professor of policy analysis and management, and economics doctoral student Catherine Maclean.

The findings, published in September by the National Bureau of Economic Research in a working paper titled "Unfit for Service: The Implications of Rising Obesity for U.S. Military Recruitment," are cause for alarm for the military branches (Army, Navy, Air Force, Marine Corps), which together must attract some 184,000 new service members each year. Fewer able-bodied recruits could also lead the Pentagon to limit its use of troops and rely instead on unmanned aircraft and private security companies to carry out missions, the paper notes.

"Almost one in four applicants to the military are rejected for being overweight or obese -- it's the most common reason for medical disqualification," Cawley said. "With an active war in Afghanistan and continuing operations in Iraq, it is well-known that the military is struggling to recruit and retain soldiers. Having a smaller pool of men and women who are fit enough to serve adds to the strain and creates even more problems for national defense."

Cawley and Maclean also found stark disparities in fitness levels of potential recruits based on race, income and college education. Compared with white females, black and Hispanic females are less likely to meet the weight standards, for instance, making it difficult for the military to achieve its diversity goals.

The study follows a similar report last spring by retired generals and admirals, which noted that more than one-fourth of young adults are medically ineligible for service. But Cawley and Maclean chart the climbing obesity rates over a much longer period, using data from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Surveys spanning 1959-2008. Moreover, the Cornell study estimates the number of civilians who meet the body fat requirements of each military branch, which had not been tracked previously. "We also accessed weight and height records measured by medical professionals, which are more accurate than self-reported data," said Maclean.

Military brass have limited options to fix the problem, Cawley said. They could relax the height-for-weight and body fat standards, but Cawley warned of additional costs to treat obesity-related conditions and associated absenteeism. "Military spending on obesity is over $1 billion annually already," Cawley said. "It's more than the military spends on treating tobacco- and alcohol-related illness combined."

One solution could be to institute more lenient weight standards for noncombat troops. "A computer programmer or cook may not need to have the same level of physical fitness as an infantryman," Cawley said.

Ultimately, Cawley said, the steep decline in military-eligible men and women illustrates the hidden costs of obesity.

"It's another example of the underappreciated public consequences of obesity," Cawley said. "We tend to think of obesity as a personal, individual health problem. But the fact that U.S. military leaders view it as a threat to national security and military readiness shows its far-reaching impact."

Explore further: Economist outlines work on managing tasks and time

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

US fitness guru urges yoga for fat soldiers

Jul 17, 2010

Asked by the US military for tips to help combat the growing problem of obesity in the ranks, a popular television fitness guru came up with an unusual answer: mind-soothing and body-bending yoga.

Recommended for you

Economist outlines work on managing tasks and time

Dec 17, 2014

"When a man knows he is to be hanged in a fortnight," said Samuel Johnson, "it concentrates his mind wonderfully." Most of us, spared such an imperative, carry on in a less-concentrated state, but it holds ...

Companies do not use online HRM effectively

Dec 15, 2014

Professor Tanya Bondarouk of the University of Twente thinks it's embarrassing : many companies and organizations are still not making effective use of e-HRM systems. These online systems can be used for a wide range of HRM-related ...

Happy-go-lucky CEOs score better returns

Dec 11, 2014

A CEO's natural sunny disposition can have an impact on the way the market reacts to announcements of company earnings, according to research from the University of British Columbia's Sauder School of Business.

User comments : 6

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

ereneon
5 / 5 (1) Oct 15, 2010
Obesity is finally turning into a national security threat. Maybe now we'll be motivated to actually do something about it.
patnclaire
1 / 5 (1) Oct 15, 2010
Yes. The leaders of this country have long known that High Fructose Corn Syrup is the cause. Because of Cuba and the sugar embargo, we are prevented from using Sugar as a sweetner. We poison ourselves with artificial sweetners. What do you expect?
dieseltaylor
not rated yet Oct 16, 2010
http://mjperry.bl...ion.html

Is probaly worth reading as the US pays heavily to keep sugar prices high, and restricts cheaper world sugar.

As for the obesity epidemic there is huge evidence that drinking sodas makes people fat in the US. So it is not just HFCS but US diet also that is leading a nation being the worlds most obese nation - a title they are vieing with the Australians who eat an entirely similar diet.

EDIT. Incidentally reading my next article from Phys Org I see this:
"It is also a common phenomenon for people to eat more if they eat while watching TV."
!
http://www.physor...ise.html
Doug_Huffman
not rated yet Oct 16, 2010
Hoo Ahh, don't ask, don't tell, don't watch TV and don't eat a kidz[sic] diet!
otto1932
not rated yet Oct 16, 2010
Does this mean DARPA and the Office of Naval Research will begin spending $$ on radical diet technologies? 'Lose 80 lbs at boot camp' could be a recruitment incentive.

It could also open the door to other 'conditioning' therapies for new recruits ala captain America- strength, endurance, neurological enhancements, psychosocial adjustments- all in the interests of national security and perceived threat.

This could be a good thing-
bhiestand
not rated yet Oct 16, 2010
Misleading title. It's not that "one in four were obese", it's that one in four exceeded the height-weight limits of the various services. Each service has its own entrance requirements, and they're usually more strict than the standards imposed on troops already in the service.

I remember back when I was going through this process... My weight was fine for Army/AF/Navy, but I was overweight by Marine standards.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.