Some Choices Are Better Than Others in Studying the Universal Solvent

April 1, 2010
Some Choices Are Better Than Others in Studying the Universal Solvent
Understanding the formation of clouds and other water-based reactions involved in climate change means understanding how water behaves at the molecular, atomic, and subatomic level. Scientists recently ranked the accuracy of different equations used in a popular modeling approach, known as density functional theory

By mixing and matching choices from a buffet of 30 to 70 options, scientists are modeling water's behavior in surface and subsurface reactions and in heterogeneous atmospheric processes such as the formation of clouds. But, how accurate are the models built with this approach, known as density functional theory (DFT)?

Scientists at Pacific Northwest and Argonne National Laboratories and the University of Buffalo ranked the accuracy of 7 different functionals or mathematical expressions used in DFT. Their article quickly became a popular download from the .

The ubiquitous nature of water means that scientists regularly model the behavior of clusters of in different environments, such as around charged species and at environmental interfaces, in biomass fuel reactors and in processes occurring in polar stratospheric clouds. Using the results of this study, scientists can better judge the accuracy of the water models they create with fast, inexpensive DFT calculations.

The team began by obtaining highly accurate data on the polarizability of a collection of up to 12 water molecules. Polarizability refers to how the of an atom or a molecule is distorted as a result of its response to an external electric field. These data served as the "gold standard" for benchmarking various DFT functionals. They obtained this data using a computationally intensive and expensive process known as the coupled cluster level of theory.

Next, they compared the impact of selecting 7 different functionals for the DFT calculations. The study demonstrated that HCTH performed quite well, as did PBE0. Both provided accurate results about the polarizability of water molecules. Using these benchmark results, scientists can now better judge the accuracy of their water models.

In performing the gold standard and the DFT calculations, the team used NWChem, a package that runs on supercomputers. This work was done as part of a Computational Grand Challenge proposal using the Chinook supercomputer at the Department of Energy's EMSL, a national scientific user facility at PNNL.

While HCTH and PBE0 offer accurate answers, the scientists want to further improve the accuracy of DFT. These parameters should provide accurate answers without adding excessive, expensive computational time. So, the scientists are continuing to investigate the theoretical requirements needed to accurately predict the properties of the planet's most common solvent: water.

Explore further: Computational actinide chemistry: Are we there yet?

More information: Hammond JR, N Govind, K Kowalski, J Autschbach, and SS Xantheas. 2009. "Accurate dipole polarizabilities of water clusters n=2-12 at the coupled-cluster level of theory and benchmarking of various density functional." Journal of Chemical Physics 131, 214103.

Related Stories

Computational actinide chemistry: Are we there yet?

August 21, 2007

Ever since the Manhattan project in World War II, actinide chemistry has been essential for nuclear science and technology. Yet scientists still seek the ability to interpret and predict chemical and physical properties of ...

Scientists Show Strontium's Swimming Skills

October 27, 2009

( -- Recently, a trio from Pacific Northwest National Laboratory and Louisiana Tech University showed that strontium ions congregate on water's surface. Their computer simulation and careful calculations finally ...

Recommended for you

New polymer creates safer fuels

October 1, 2015

Before embarking on a transcontinental journey, jet airplanes fill up with tens of thousands of gallons of fuel. In the event of a crash, such large quantities of fuel increase the severity of an explosion upon impact. Researchers ...

Researchers print inside gels to create unique shapes

September 30, 2015

(—A team of researchers at the University of Florida has taken the technique of printing objects inside of a gel a step further by using a highly shear-rate sensitive gel. In their paper published in the journal ...

How a molecular motor untangles protein

October 1, 2015

A marvelous molecular motor that untangles protein in bacteria may sound interesting, yet perhaps not so important. Until you consider the hallmarks of several neurodegenerative diseases—Huntington's disease has tangled ...

Anti-aging treatment for smart windows

October 1, 2015

Electrochromic windows, so-called 'smart windows', share a well-known problem with rechargeable batteries – their limited lifespan. Researchers at Uppsala University have now worked out an entirely new way to rejuvenate ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.