# Analyzing Effects Of Hoops Ball Hog

##### March 17, 2010 By Phillip F. Schewe, ISNS

Fans will have noticed that when a basketball team's best player sits out for a while the team will sometimes actually do better than when the star is playing. Concepts from the mathematical science called game theory help to explain why this is.

Game theory seeks to show how operate -- things such as automobiles in a crowded highway, ants in a pile, or in a colony. For the problem of traffic, if all cars on a road cooperate by moving smoothly -- and not cutting each other off -- the flow will be maintained even if the density of cars is high. However, as soon as a few drivers aggressively try to move through the formation of cars the whole formation can slow down dramatically, resulting in a traffic jam.

Brian Skinner, a research fellow at the University of Minnesota, has shown how to extend this reasoning into an analysis of basketball. Modeling each play as a pathway, he has analyzed the process by which a team moves the ball down to the opponent's basket and tries to score. Surprisingly, you get the best results -- and the highest score -- if you share the ball more than seems reasonable. Running your offense in the most efficient way, said Skinner, isn't the same as taking the highest-percentage shot each time down the court.

When a particular star player is used more often than other his efficiency begins to decline. This is because the defense begins to focus more intently on that player, thereby making it harder for him to score. Sharing the ball, even to the extent of letting the less talented players shoot, is equivalent to spreading traffic over multiple roads instead of cramming all the cars onto any one road. It prevents the roads from getting congested, which results in everyone getting a better commute on average.

In sports an important factor is keeping the defense honest. Consequently it is important to spread out your offense over multiple options. In baseball, to take another sports analogy, pitchers will not always throw their best pitch all the time; even at the risk of giving batters an increased chance of getting a hit at any moment, the pitcher feels it is better to keep the batter guessing as to the nature of the next pitch. Similarly, in football, passing the ball results in a higher average yardage gain than running the ball, yet most teams will combine the two offensive methods in an effort to maximize scoring.

Skinner argues that in basketball it pays to let some of the lower percentage shooters on the team have a chance rather than always letting the star player drive the offense. What Skinner is proposing is a way to formalize the reasoning of keeping the defense honest, and to calculate the optimal level of mixing up your plays.

Skinner suggests that ball-hogging can be detrimental to a team's success. He uses the phrase the price of anarchy, which in is the name for the action by which an individual -- perhaps a selfish driver or a star shooter -- will disrupt an otherwise successful play strategy.

How about defense? In his model Skinner assumes that a defense always focuses on a given player when that player gets increased use. In reality, the defense has the right to choose how much to focus on any given player, and Skinner plans to take more defensive strategies into account.

Explore further: Nothing But Net: The Physics of Free-Throw Shooting

## Related Stories

#### Nothing But Net: The Physics of Free-Throw Shooting

November 4, 2009

(PhysOrg.com) -- Pay attention, Shaq: Two North Carolina State University engineers have figured out the best way to shoot a free throw - a frequently underappreciated skill that gets more important as the game clock winds ...

#### A convincing calculation: ten soccer players ensure excitement

March 13, 2006

One ball, two goals and 22 soccer players – and the game can begin. But why are there ten players of one team on the field and no more or less? This is what Metin Tolan, professor for experimental physics at the University ...

#### New World Cup football will unsettle goalkeepers, predicts scientist

June 7, 2006

The new football that will be used for the first time in the World Cup’s opening game today is likely to “bamboozle” goalkeepers at some stage of the tournament, a leading scientist has warned.

#### Injuries to high school baseball players becoming more serious

June 2, 2008

Although the overall rate of high school baseball-related injuries has decreased within the last 10 years, the severity of injuries that occur has increased, according to a new study conducted by researchers at the Center ...

#### New technique developed to evaluate basketball players

June 5, 2009

A team of Spanish and American researchers has developed a method to evaluate basketball players that will, they say, better meet the requirements of the sport's trainers and experts. The technique uses mathematical models ...

#### Athlete's 'rituals' important for overcoming performance anxiety

January 31, 2007

Dry mouth, sweaty palms and rapid heart rate are just a few symptoms of increased anxiety, the kind an athlete might feel before the big game. Those symptoms drop off quickly, but psychological factors hang around to influence ...

## Recommended for you

#### Evaluation of scientific rigor in animal research

December 2, 2016

The "reproducibility crisis" in biomedical research has led to questions about the scientific rigor in animal research, and thus the ethical justification of animal experiments. In research publishing in the Open Access journals ...

#### One day, many ideas: Future of Mind 2016 illuminates NYC (Part 1)

December 1, 2016

(Phys.org)—The shape that human cognition may take over the coming next half-century has become increasingly difficult to foresee. Moreover, accelerating advances in science, mathematics, computing, and culture – including ...

#### Black Death 'plague pit' discovered at 14th-century monastery hospital

December 1, 2016

A mass burial of bodies, known to be victims of the Black Death, has been discovered at the site of a 14th-century monastery hospital at Thornton Abbey, Lincolnshire.

#### Scientists discover new material from Sutton Hoo ship burial

December 1, 2016

Scientists have discovered a new material to add to the collection of treasures from the Sutton Hoo ship burial - bitumen from the Middle East.

#### Researchers find evidence of original 1620 Plymouth settlement

November 30, 2016

Three hundred and ninety-five years after Pilgrims celebrated the first Thanksgiving in Plymouth, Massachusetts, researchers from UMass Boston's Andrew Fiske Memorial Center for Archaeological Research can say they have definitively ...

#### Scientists find new conclusions for how sauropod claws were used

November 30, 2016

Paleontologists at the Cleveland Museum of Natural History and Dickinson Museum Center (North Dakota) have just published new research describing the behavior of sauropod dinosaurs, the largest animals to ever walk the earth. ...