Freezing point of supercooled water varies with electric charge

February 8, 2010 by Lin Edwards report
'Feather' ice. Image: Craig Thom, via Wikipedia

( -- Just as water can be superheated and remain liquid above the boiling point if there is no nucleating surface (such as a surface defect or a speck of dust), it can also become supercooled and remain liquid well below its freezing point of 0°C. Now scientists have found that supercooled water freezes at different temperatures in the presence of a surface with a positive or negative charge.

In the absence of a charged surface supercooled water can freeze at temperatures as low as -40°C, and it has been known for over 150 years that the presence of an can affect the freezing point (a phenomenon known as electrofreezing). The dominant hypothesis for the effect is that because are polar, with a small negative charge at one end and a positive charge at the other, an electric field would align them according to their charge. It has been difficult to study this phenomenon because charged surfaces (such as metals) act as nucleating agents, and therefore trigger freezing.

Igor Lubomirsky and colleagues from the Weizmann Institute of Science in Rehovot, Israel, have solved the dilemma by creating a charge on a non-nucleating pyroelectric material surface, to allow the electrical effects alone to be examined.

The scientists used lithium tantalate (LiTaO3) and thin films of strontium titanate (SrTiO3) as the non-nucleating surfaces, and placed them in a humid room. They then cooled the room until formed on the surfaces and then lowered the temperature even further until the droplets froze.

The results showed that in the absence of an electric field the water droplets froze at an average of -12.5°C. If the surface was negatively charged the freezing point was -18°C, while if the surface was positively charged the droplets froze at -7°C. Lubomirsky said the difference in freezing temperatures was surprising. The exact mechanism is unclear, and the team are investigating.

They also found they could freeze liquid supercooled water by heating it. With the surface of an LiTaO3 crystal negatively charged, the water was kept liquid at -11ºC for around 10 minutes, but after the charge dissipated the temperature was increased to induce a positive charge on the surface, and the water froze at -8 ºC. Powder x-ray diffraction studies showed that freezing on the positive surface began at the solid/water interface, while on the negative surface freezing began at the air/ interface.

The experiments demonstrated that if the surface charge is controlled ice formation can be either enhanced or suppressed, and this could possibly have an application in the cryogenic freezing of tissues and blood, or in cloud seeding.

The study was published on February 5 in the journal Science.

Explore further: 'Cold' Mars Could Have Harbored Liquid Water

More information: David Ehre, Etay Lavert, Meir Lahav and Igor Lubomirsky, Science, 2010, DOI:10.1126/science.1178085

Related Stories

'Cold' Mars Could Have Harbored Liquid Water

June 1, 2009

( -- A new NASA study provides further evidence that Martian minerals dissolved in water could have kept that water from freezing, even on a cold, early Mars.

Scientists Observe Liquid Water Below Freezing

June 24, 2009

( -- Below 0 °C, water turns to ice. But beyond that, or below about -75 °C, the ice may turn back into liquid water. While scientists have previously predicted this phase transition with computer simulations, ...

Model Suggests Origins of Mars Gullies

February 9, 2009

University of Arkansas researchers have used chemistry and geology to create a model that may explain the mystery of how modern-day gullies form on the surface of Mars.

Recommended for you

Researchers discover new rules for quasicrystals

October 25, 2016

Crystals are defined by their repeating, symmetrical patterns and long-range order. Unlike amorphous materials, in which atoms are randomly packed together, the atoms in a crystal are arranged in a predictable way. Quasicrystals ...

Scientists discover particles similar to Majorana fermions

October 25, 2016

Majorana fermions were first proposed by the physicist Ettore Majorana in 1937. They are fermion particles that are also their own antiparticles. These fermions are vital to the research of superconducting materials and topological ...

Towards better metallic glasses

October 25, 2016

Researchers from the University of Bristol have used state-of-the-art computer simulation to test a theory from the 1950s that when atoms organise themselves into 3D pentagons they supress crystallisation.

3-D printed metamaterial shrinks when heated

October 25, 2016

Members of Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory's Additive Manufacturing Initiative are among a group of researchers who have developed 3D printed materials with a unique property—instead of expanding when heated, they ...

The quantum sniffer dog

October 24, 2016

As humans, we sniff out different scents and aromas using chemical receptors in our noses. In technological gas detection, however, there are a whole host of other methods available. One such method is to use infrared lasers, ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Feb 08, 2010
Awesome observation! I never would have thought of it. seems like something we would have noticed long ago. Water really is some strange stuff. Its bonds form a kind of mutable structure even in the liquid state. Almost like a liquid crystal.

and check out this curiosity. The test seems a bit small, but with a p value of .001, the results were highly statistically significant
http://www.intern..._EXPLORE (2).pdf
not rated yet Feb 09, 2010
non-nucleating surfaces and negative charges could find use as ice prevention on airplane wings

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.