Making Quantum Behavior Observable Using Optical Levitation

January 26, 2010 By Lisa Zyga feature
A dielectric sphere trapped in an optical cavity can enable quantum behavior to emerge. The large trapping beam intensity (red) provides an optical potential that traps the sphere near an antinode. A second, weaker cavity mode (green) cools the motion of the sphere. Image credit: D. E. Chang, et al.

( -- Perhaps one of the biggest challenges of modern physics is figuring out how to realize and take advantage of strange quantum behaviors in progressively larger and more complex systems. Progress along this front is expected to shed insight into the nature of quantum mechanics and lead to many novel applications. With this goal in mind, scientists have recently proposed a unique approach that involves optically levitating a nano-mechanical system in order to cool it to its quantum ground state, where the amount of motion of the system reaches the fundamental minimum set by intrinsic quantum fluctuations.

The researchers, Darrick E. Chang, et al., from institutions in the US and Austria, are publishing their study in an upcoming issue of the . A similar proposal has simultaneously been put forth by researchers at the Max Planck Institute in Garching, Germany.

“Over the next several years, there will be a concerted effort by a number of groups worldwide to observe and manipulate in progressively larger and more complex mechanical systems,” Chang, from the California Institute of Technology, told “A major obstacle is the interaction between these systems and their environments, which tends to ‘leak away’ the quantum nature of these systems and return them to classical states. We've proposed a technique that can allow these interactions to be dramatically suppressed, by using optical forces to levitate such systems and remove them from any direct contact with material surroundings. We have shown in detail that this enables to emerge in the case of a levitated nanosphere, but we anticipate that these ideas can also be applied to a wide class of other systems and over a large range of system size scales.”

As the scientists explain, in order to make a system’s quantum behavior observable, the system must be actively cooled to temperatures much colder than the surrounding environment. A key challenge to this cooling is overcoming the tendency of the environment to re-heat the system back to the ambient temperature. One possible solution is to work in cryogenic environments where the ambient temperature itself is reduced, an approach that is being taken by a number of groups worldwide.

“Using cryogenic setups is certainly a viable approach to reduce the effects of the environment,” Chang said. “As one attempts to observe more exotic quantum effects and use larger systems, however, it is likely that moving to cryogenic environments alone will not be sufficient. This motivates the search for other techniques to suppress environmental interactions, which can be applied as an alternative or in conjunction with cryogenics.”

In the new study, Chang and his coauthors have proposed a novel approach in which one isolates the system from the environment to such a degree that re-heating becomes a very inefficient process, even when the environment sits at room temperature. In this scheme, isolation is achieved by optically levitating an entire nano-mechanical system inside an optical cavity, which removes direct contact of the system with any other material. An optical cavity consists of an arrangement of mirrors that confines light inside of it by repeatedly reflecting the light waves off the mirrors. The force from the light is powerful enough to counteract the force of gravity, creating an optical trap that can suspend small, light-weight objects inside the cavity.

The researchers calculated that an optically levitated silica nanosphere can be optically self-cooled to its ground state starting from room temperature. In this scenario, the nanosphere would interact with two optical modes of the cavity. One mode would provide an optical trap for the sphere, while a second, weaker mode would provide a radiation pressure cooling force. The scientists explain that this system is an extreme example of environmental isolation in which the nanosphere is mechanically isolated as well as thermally decoupled from its surroundings. In fact, the isolation is so good that quantum mechanical effects should be able to persist for times much longer than in conventional nano-mechanical systems, even those in cryogenic environments.

While ground-state cooling should also be achievable in the near future with other systems, the scientists believe that the levitated system is an elegant example of how quantum effects can emerge and be robust even at room temperature. For example, the scientists predict that quantum entanglement initially shared between two light modes could be transferred onto the motion of two nanospheres trapped in separate cavities, which could then be observed. Other potential applications include exploring fundamental material limits, investigating nanoscale properties, and realizing novel quantum hybrid architectures.

“There are a number of potential applications for quantum opto-mechanical systems,” Chang said. “One can imagine coupling such systems to other quantum systems to enable tasks such as quantum information transfer or quantum state manipulation. For example, work along these lines has been done by Dan Rugar at IBM, who has pioneered techniques to detect single electron spins in solid-state environments using opto-mechanics. It is also possible that opto-mechanical systems can be used as a novel platform for realizing nonlinear optical processes, by suitable manipulation of the interaction between light and mechanical motion.”

Explore further: Report: Scientists 'teleport' two photons

More information: D. E. Chang, et al. “Cavity opto-mechanics using an optically levitated nanosphere.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. doi:10.1073/pnas.0912969107


Related Stories

Physicists working up from atoms to Schrodinger's cat

January 28, 2009

( -- Schrodinger's cat, a macroscopic object that is both alive and dead at the same time, illustrates the strangeness of quantum mechanics. While such quantum properties have been widely observed for electrons ...

A solid case of entanglement

January 11, 2010

Physicists have finally managed to demonstrate quantum entanglement of spatially separated electrons in solid state circuitry.

Recommended for you

Seeing quantum motion

August 28, 2015

Consider the pendulum of a grandfather clock. If you forget to wind it, you will eventually find the pendulum at rest, unmoving. However, this simple observation is only valid at the level of classical physics—the laws ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (1) Jan 26, 2010
The real question remains: will this let me separate entangled particles sufficiently far enough so that it will be possible to build long distance instant communications (e.g. from here to the moon without the 1+s delay)?
5 / 5 (2) Jan 26, 2010

Most of the currently accepted theories don't allow for transmission of information faster than c, even using entangled particles.

Are you referring to a specific theory that predicts that this is possible? If so, perhaps you could explain, briefly, how one would go about setting up the test and transmitting a bit FTL.
not rated yet Jan 27, 2010
now to make laser fields of such ablative technologies for plasmon surface field displacement, everything inside the field stays stationary, everything outside the field is displaced through interaction; light speed travel along energy beams 2010? some could call it quantum teleportation
not rated yet Jan 27, 2010
Most of the currently accepted theories don't allow for transmission of information faster than c, even using entangled particles.

One should note that this only goes for c in vacuum. For light travelling in materials (where c is always lower than in vacuum) the movement at 'superluminal speeds' in that material (as is the case in the article) is nothing new. Even electrons can achive greater than c speeds in the right medium (e.g. as the cause of Cherenkov radiation in light water reactors)
not rated yet Jan 27, 2010
But for the bulk of the journey, between the Earth and the Moon there is vacuum.
3 / 5 (2) Jan 28, 2010
Information cannot be conveyed in FTL, however, antialias. So far, while entanglement and other theories look interesting, their capabilities of ever transferring even the slightest amount of information is nil.
not rated yet Feb 05, 2010
how one would go about setting up the test and transmitting a bit FTL.

Assuming one can create entanglement and maintain the entanglement indefinitely you could do FTL communication.

Create a pair of entangled particles and install one on Earth, and the second in a shuttle. Allow a single characteristic to be your "bit" for example, spin, up spin is 0, down spin is 1. Now start changing the spin to transmit your zeros and ones.

For larger bandwidth create more particle pairs. Like the switches on a register of memory, the data can be sent and received instantly.

FTL communication is being considered possible by those within the field of quantum computing. The supposition that classical measurement must be included to produce the final result is not wholly supported.

Right now we don't know. Finding out will either revolutionize our world, or be an interesting and expensive study. I hope we all get to see the end result when the retrocausality experiments r done.
not rated yet Feb 05, 2010
Information cannot be conveyed in FTL, however, antialias.

In a medium, you can beat (that medium's) speed of light - for information transmission as well as for particle motion (Cherenkov radiation is an example of the latter, phase coded transmission is an example of the former)

For vacuum that isn't possible, though.
Have to be careful when we use the tern FTL here.

Now start changing the spin to transmit your zeros and ones.

No. You cannot 'change' the spins. The particle must be in an indeterminate state and you can only _measure_ it (and be assured that the one at the other end will come out the same). If you start flipping spins you are breaking the entanglement. The formerly entangled object on the other side will not change its spin as well.
1 / 5 (1) Feb 05, 2010
Ah, yes, antialias, you are correct in your terminology. I made the mistake in my assumptions of your comment.
not rated yet Feb 05, 2010
If you start flipping spins you are breaking the entanglement. The formerly entangled object on the other side will not change its spin as well.

They said the same of quantum teleportation, until we did it.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.