The Meandering Channels of Mars

December 10, 2009 by Michael Schirber
A meandering river in Siberia. Image Credit: Ólafur Ingólfsson,

Sinuous channels on the Martian surface may be evidence of relatively recent rainfall. Researchers plan to test this hypothesis by studying sinuous streams on Earth.

The surface of Mars is littered with channels that appear to be the work of ancient water flows. Indeed, some of these channels meander back and forth like slow-moving streams on our planet. Channels can be carved by lava, wind and , but these processes can't explain all the features on Mars.

"We've gotten over the hump and can now agree that water flowed on the in the past," says Alan Howard of the University of Virginia.

But how much and when is still unclear. Howard believes the meandering channels on Mars may tell us a lot about the wet history of our planetary neighbor.

A sinuous channel in the Aeolis Planum region of Mars taken by the HiRISE camera on the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter. Image Credit: NASA/JPL/University of Arizona

Howard and a group of researchers will be tromping into the desert and the arctic to find terrestrial "meanders" that might explain their counterparts on Mars.

On Earth, meandering streams occur where the floodplain is resistant to erosion. Often this is because the stream banks are held firm by grass and tree roots.

"Mars almost certainly didn't have vegetation like that," Howard says.

So what might have kept in place? Howard and his colleagues have a list of possible mechanisms: clay, ice, chemical processes. They will be studying how these mechanisms create sinuous channels on Earth to see if they can pinpoint the best representation for what created similar channels on Mars.

The work is funded by as part of its Mars Fundamental Research program.

Martian hydrology

Channels can be found all over the Martian landscape. Many are braided in a way that resembles river deltas on Earth.

But there are two areas on the red planet -- the Eberswalde Crater delta and the Aeolis/Zephyra Plana region -- where the channels snake their way through the now barren landscape. The channels were most likely carved by runoff from precipitation, Howard says. But that doesn't jive well with their age, which is estimated to be around 2 billion years old or even younger.

"The width and branching character of the channels is consistent with episodes of rain or snow, but it seems difficult to have precipitation that recently," Howard says.

False color image of gully channels in a crater in the southern highlands of Mars, taken by the High Resolution Image Science Experiment (HiRISE) camera on the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter. The gullies emanating from the rocky cliffs near the crater's rim (upper left) show meandering and braided patterns typical of water-carved channels. North is approximately up and illumination is from the left. The scale is 26 centimeters per pixel. Image credit: NASA/JPL/University of Arizona

Liquid water was thought to have disappeared from the surface of Mars more than 3 billion years ago. However, it's possible that water flowed after that - perhaps due to a large meteor impact or volcanic eruption that melted ice and created a wet micro-climate for a short period of time in the recent past.

But Howard and his colleagues wonder if such a brief wet spell could create meandering rivers in the martian landscape. Are there examples on Earth that could help solve the mystery?

Making hay over clay

Meandering rivers on Earth typically are found where vegetation traps fine sediment to eventually form a layer of cohesive material that is resistant to erosion.

But there are places where streams meander even though there’s not much vegetation around. Howard and his group have identified several such sites in the Nevada desert.

"We suspect clay sediment is providing the necessary cohesion," Howard says of these sites.

In the coming months, the team will visit these desert meanders to study their geology and test whether clay is indeed able to explain the meandering.

Clay has been detected on Mars in various locations, but it's mostly associated with earlier - supposedly wetter - epochs on Mars.

"Clay implies a considerable amount of weathering," Howard explains.

If the meandering channels on Mars formed because of clay in the soil, that would imply an appreciably wetter environment for a longer time and at a later epoch than scientists have imagined.

Aerial photo of a meandering stream near Barrow, Alaska. Image Credit: U.S. Geological Survey

Other possibilities

There may be other ways to make a waterway meander, besides clay.

Ice in the flow of water could hinder erosion of the banks. Howard's team plans to go to Alaska, near the town of Barrow, to see if ice is playing a part in the formation of meanders there.

Another possibility is chemical hardening of the stream bed. In arid environments, minerals deposited in the ground can cement together to form a hard thin layer. So-called "duricrusts" are common on Earth (and have been found on Mars), but the team has yet to find a meandering stream flowing through one. Howard says that the crusts take centuries to form, which is perhaps too long to develop the erosion boundaries needed for meandering.

The situation could, of course, be different on Mars. The climate is cooler, the surface is more iron-rich, and the gravity is just 38 percent that of Earth. This last difference is something that the researchers will be looking at closely to see what effect it has on channel formation.

Lastly, Howard has considered that microbial crusts - the closest that Mars could presumably have gotten to "vegetation" - may have provided soil cohesion.

"It would be obviously revolutionary if organisms were responsible for the meandering on , but we really have to eliminate all other possibilities first," Howard says.


Explore further: Valley networks on Mars formed during long period of episodic flooding

Related Stories

Clay Studies Alter View of Early Mars Environment

July 18, 2007

A study of the thermodynamics of clays found on Mars suggests that little carbon dioxide could have been present during their formation, which contradicts a popular theory of the early Martian atmosphere and will send researchers ...

Mineral discovery explains Mars' landscape

October 23, 2006

A Queen's University researcher has discovered a mineral that could explain the mountainous landscape of Mars, and have implications for NASA's next mission to the planet.

Life leaves subtle signature in the lay of the land

January 26, 2006

One of the paradoxes of recent explorations of the Martian surface is that the more we see of the planet, the more it looks like Earth, despite a very big difference: Complex life forms have existed for billions of years ...

Living, Meandering River Constructed

September 29, 2009

( -- In a feat of reverse-engineering, Christian Braudrick of University of California at Berkeley and three coauthors have successfully built and maintained a scale model of a living meandering gravel-bed river ...

Recommended for you

STEREO—10 years of revolutionary solar views

October 26, 2016

Launched 10 years ago, on Oct. 25, 2006, the twin spacecraft of NASA's STEREO mission – short for Solar and Terrestrial Relations Observatory – have given us unprecedented views of the sun, including the first-ever simultaneous ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

2 / 5 (1) Dec 10, 2009
"Mars almost certainly didn't have vegetation like that," Howard says. "

Based on what? Unreleased public paid for information or dogma.

If Scotland was tropical before the last ice age (and we know that CO2 couldn't have been the cause) then why couldn't Mars have been much warmer, and wetter, in the past w/ grass growing, like in the present day arctic?
1 / 5 (1) Dec 10, 2009
Scotland reference: http://www.physor...861.html

"It would be obviously revolutionary if organisms were responsible for the meandering on Mars, but we really have to eliminate all other possibilities first," Howard says."

Why, because the life issue could be too upsetting? Or because Life detection instrumentation hasn't been sent to Mars since the Viking experiment (early 70's) showed diurnal release of CO2? We have been told this was not by life but by some new, unknown mysterious chemical process. As a chemist, I know this is nonsense.
4.5 / 5 (2) Dec 11, 2009
As the late Carl Sagan said: "Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence". Remember how just about everybody used to believe that Venus was like a primitive, carbonaceous Earth, dripping with humidity because of the cloud cover which was all that could be observed. Then the soviet Venera probes showed the surface conditions were hellish, and bone dry.
The hopes of finding life on Mars might likewise turn out to be wishful thinking.
4.5 / 5 (2) Dec 11, 2009
Recent research of Venus has suggested that the 'totally dry' picture may be overstated, and that stable surface and/or sub-surface liquids (between the poles and the tropics) may provide conditions for 'extremophiles' which live in conditions that we could not survive.

It's not the picture of paradise that the Victorians imagined, but both Mars and Venus may support "life, Jim, but not as we know it"

I wish Carl were still with us, and that he had the lobbying power he has achieved since his death. He would not have us he discussing going to Mars, he would have us there by now, burying our first pioneers in Martian soil. Perhaps even being the first to go there, showing us the way.

No new territory has been conquered without cost, but we are going to have to pay to get out of the mess we are currently starting to understand.
5 / 5 (1) Dec 11, 2009
Mars almost certainly didn't have vegetation like that," Howard says
Mr Howard how can you possibly exclude vegetation on mars at one time Have you been there before I think if you had been there it was most of the green house effect plunged Mars into a deep freeze But then 20 years ago you would have thought that mars had NO Water either !!!!!

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.