'Wedding Cake' Images Display Transitions between Exotic Quantum States

Aug 20, 2009
A high-resolution absorption image of a heterogeneous sample of Mott-insulating, superfluid and normal gases of ultracold atoms in an optical lattice. Each pixel corresponds to a square 660nm on a side, and the optical resolution is 1.3 micron. Credit: Cheng Chin, James Franck Institute, University of Chicago

(PhysOrg.com) -- Transitions are exciting. And at temperatures close to absolute zero, studying the transition from one quantum phase to another tantalizes physicists looking for a deeper understanding of the fundamental laws of the universe.

Now a team of scientists at the University of Chicago has created the first direct images of the transition between phases of ultracold gas, as it changes from normal to superfluid to Mott , making it possible to "see" this phenomenon as it happens.

"These are the first direct images of a complete physical system in situ, allowing us to unambiguously observe certain unique features of the Mott insulating state," explained post-doctoral student Nathan Gemelke.

In a paper appearing in the journal Nature, Gemelke and his co-authors describe the most striking visual feature of this phase transition--a many-layered wedding cake structure.

The 'wedding cake' structure shows the density profile of a heterogeneous mixture of Mott insulating, superfluid and normal phases of ultracold cesium atoms trapped in an optical lattice. "The different layers of the cake are formed by Mott insulating domains of successively higher particle numbers, and their flatness is a result of their incompressibility," said Dr. Nathan Gemelke, of the University of Chicago. "The edges as we go from one layer of the cake to the next are superfluid regions, where the density varies continuously," he said. "As the temperature is increased, the cake melts like a multi-tiered ice cream cake, and smears out the edges of the layers." Credit: Cheng Chin, James Franck Institute, University of Chicago

The Mott Insulator Observed

"The Mott insulator phenomenon was first observed in ultracold atomic gases in 2002 by the group of Ted Hänsch, at the Max-Planck institute for Quantum Optics in Munich, Germany, and has been a subject of intense research ever since," said Cheng Chin, Gemelke's co-author and an assistant professor at the University of Chicago.

A Mott insulator is a special phase of matter, usually formed at very low temperatures, in which certain materials that should conduct electricity act as electrical insulators, due to unusual interactions between electrons. The system studied in Chicago is the ultracold atom equivalent of a Mott insulator.

To make the insulator, the Chicago team trapped individual atoms using a cross-section of laser beams to create an "optical lattice," something like marbles trapped in the individual sections of an egg carton.

"In a Mott insulator, there is exactly one atom at every site, or two, or three, but never a mixture of, say, one here, two there, etc.," Chin explained.

Three Co-existing Phases

According to Gemelke, the Mott insulator phase sometimes co-exists with superfluid and normal gas phases. Superfluids are another exotic quantum material phase that forms at temperatures near absolute zero.

"The superfluid and normal phases of the ultracold gas will react to small pressures by changing their volumes, and will react to small forces by flowing freely," explained Gemelke.

"In contrast, the Mott insulator phase has a constant density," he said. "Even when it's trapped, if you squeeze it gently, its volume will not change, which means it is incompressible. And if you apply a small force across it, particles do not flow through it, because it acts as an insulator."

These three false-color images, from left, depict the density of cesium atoms in a superfluid (conducting) state, a transition state and an insulating state. The original sample consisted of a single-layer of cesium atoms that formed a sheet measuring 80 microns in diameter, barely visible to the naked eye. Green indicates the lowest density of atoms. Red indicates a high, constant density. Physicists call this a plateau, which University of Chicago scientists have observed for the first time. (Image courtesy of Nathan Gemelke and Cheng Chin)

The researchers took advantage of the differences between phases to create visual images of the system by measuring the density of the trapped gas.

"In two dimensions, the normal, superfluid and Mott insulating phases can be identified by spatially resolved in-situ imaging," Gemelke said. These two-dimensional images appear as bullseye targets, with denser material showing up as dark rings. The Mott insulator phase image remains a single color all the way through, because its density does not increase.

"In three dimensional systems, the image integrates the density along the line-of-sight, so the measurements represent the combined properties of several phases," Gemelke said.

The result looks like a colorful, multi-layered wedding cake.

"The different layers of the cake are formed by Mott insulating domains of successively higher particle numbers, and their flatness results from their incompressibility," says Gemelke.

"The edges as we go from one layer of the cake to the next are superfluid regions, where the density varies continuously," he said. "As the temperature is increased, the cake melts like a multi-tiered ice cream cake, and smears out the edges of the layers. By measuring its shape, we can infer the temperature-and unlike an ice cream cake, the result is within fifteen parts-per-billion of ."

Worth more than 1,000 words

The researchers hope to apply the understanding they gain from studying simple quantum gases like this one to the development of a wide range of more subtle and potentially useful new materials, Chin said.

"We are excited to extend this research into basic studies of transitions--that is to say, transitions between phases which can occur at zero temperature," he said. "Very fascinating and general phenomena can be observed near these types of transitions, and to have such a simple and readily studied example on the laboratory bench is a great commodity."

"We are surprised by how true the adage is that a picture is worth a thousand words," added Gemlke. "Each image we take of these systems is a high-resolution snapshot into the life of a quantum gas, including all the bumps and wriggles we hope to describe with theory. Every time we think we have extracted all the information we could hope for from an image, we realize there is more to study."

More information: Gemelke, Nathan; Zhang, Xibo; Hung, Chen-Lung; and Chin, Cheng, “In-situ Observation of Incompressible Mott-Insulating Domains of Ultracold Atomic Gases,” Nature, Aug. 20, 2009.

Provided by NSF

Explore further: Endless oscillations: A theoretical study on quantum systems

Related Stories

Investigating new materials with ultracold atoms

Dec 04, 2008

The investigation of complex materials such as high-temperature superconductors is problematic because of the presence of disorder and many competing interactions in real crystalline materials. "This makes ...

'March Madness' effects observed in ultracold gases

Mar 31, 2006

Physicists at Harvard University, George Mason University and the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) have discovered new quantum effects in ultracold gases that may lead to improved understanding ...

A way to detect a new quantum phase

Sep 27, 2006

“So many systems in physics look different and do different things,” Luming Duan tells PhysOrg.com. “But when you get to fundamentals they look very similar. We are looking for new fundamentals that can help us und ...

Atom 'noise' may help design quantum computers

Mar 02, 2007

As if building a computer out of rubidium atoms and laser beams weren't difficult enough, scientists sometimes have to work as if blindfolded: The quirks of quantum physics can cause correlations between the ...

Recommended for you

Physicists solve quantum tunneling mystery

May 27, 2015

An international team of scientists studying ultrafast physics have solved a mystery of quantum mechanics, and found that quantum tunneling is an instantaneous process.

How spacetime is built by quantum entanglement

May 27, 2015

A collaboration of physicists and a mathematician has made a significant step toward unifying general relativity and quantum mechanics by explaining how spacetime emerges from quantum entanglement in a more ...

Experiment confirms quantum theory weirdness

May 27, 2015

The bizarre nature of reality as laid out by quantum theory has survived another test, with scientists performing a famous experiment and proving that reality does not exist until it is measured.

Quantum computer emulated by a classical system

May 27, 2015

(Phys.org)—Quantum computers are inherently different from their classical counterparts because they involve quantum phenomena, such as superposition and entanglement, which do not exist in classical digital ...

User comments : 4

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Aug 20, 2009
Does anyone else remember the first use of the wedding cake analogy in nuclear physics?
not rated yet Aug 20, 2009
This picture basically corresponds this particle simulation, illustrating the ball of dense gas, tied by its gravity:


At the boundary the motion of particles is free like inside of gas, bellow surface particles are tied to separate places in hexagonal lattice (Mott insulating phase), while under highest pressure at the center they're forming chaotic fluid, filled by foamy density fluctuations (stringy quantum superfluid). It can be easily simulated on common PC at real time.

..In a Mott insulator, there is exactly one atom at every site, or two, or three, but never a mixture of, say, one here, two there..
This is not quite true, especially at real case of Mott-Hubbard transitions. In real Mott insulators here's no artificial subject, which keeps the regular lattice of atoms (an optical lattice), so that real Mott phases with different number of particles per node of grid are often mixed together in the same way, like on pictures above presented by Gemelke.
not rated yet Aug 20, 2009
..remember the first use of the wedding cake analogy in nuclear physics?..
I do believe, the scenario presented above is relevant at all levels of observable reality. Density fluctuations of environment forms a dense gas, which forms crystalline, fluid and chaotic phase, the density fluctuations of which are forming another level of gas, and so on, repeatedly. In AWT here's no finite number of nested levels, although their visibility from particular level remains limited by geometry of mutually overlapping interactions.
3 / 5 (1) Aug 20, 2009
Mott-Hubbard transitions can be studied even at quite macroscopical level at the case of so called plasma crystals: systems of tiny charged particles compressed in electric field.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.