Grilling with charcoal less climate-friendly than grilling with propane

May 12, 2009

Do biofuels always create smaller carbon footprints than their fossil-fuel competitors? Not necessarily, finds a paper published in Elsevier’s Environmental Impact Assessment Review. The article, “Charcoal versus LPG grilling: a carbon-footprint comparison,” reports that in the UK, the carbon footprint for charcoal grilling is almost three times as large as that for LPG* grilling.

The overwhelming factors behind the difference, notes author Eric Johnson, are that as a fuel, LPG is dramatically more efficient than charcoal in its production and considerably more efficient in cooking. Charcoal is produced by heating wood in a kiln; commercial yields of charcoal are only in the 20-35% range, i.e. most of the rest of the wood is converted to gas and emitted into the atmosphere. Yields of LPG, by contrast, are greater than 90%.

LPG grills are akin to conventional cookers and ovens, in that they have power ratings and can easily be switched on and off. By contrast, charcoal grills do not offer easy mechanisms for regulating fuel consumption, and Johnson explained: “The primary factor in determining fuel consumption is the griller’s loading, which is determined by the amount of charcoal that is used along with the quality and quantity of starting-aid that is required. “

Developing countries, primarily in Africa, are likely to be the source of charcoal loaded in the UK, the study points out. Contrary to a claim by the European Commission that “Trade in charcoal from Africa to the EU is not significant,” in 2008, the UK imported 80% of its charcoal from developing countries, and 50% of its charcoal from Africa.  Nearly 70% of the total import comes from South Africa, Argentina, Namibia and Nigeria.

Forest stocks in the latter three countries are in decline, according to the UN’s Food and Agricultural Organization, as they are on a global scale, especially in the developing world.

*Liquefied petroleum gas (LPG), often referred to as propane, is a mixture of mostly propane and butane.
More information: “Charcoal versus LPG grilling: A carbon-footprint comparison”, Environmental Impact Assessment Review, doi:10.1016/j.eiar.2009.02.004

Explore further: MIT team cooks up simple fuel recipe

Related Stories

MIT team cooks up simple fuel recipe

August 1, 2007

MIT student Jules Walter has seen firsthand the impact of deforestation in his native Haiti: Nearly 98 percent of the island's forests are gone, and more trees are being cut down every year.

Mountain gorillas in danger in the Congo

August 21, 2007

Conservationists in the Democratic Republic of the Congo believe the charcoal trade is killing mountain gorillas at the Virunga National park.

Recommended for you

New study sheds light on end of Snowball Earth period

August 24, 2015

The second ice age during the Cryogenian period was not followed by the sudden and chaotic melting-back of the ice as previously thought, but ended with regular advances and retreats of the ice, according to research published ...

Earth's mineralogy unique in the cosmos

August 26, 2015

New research from a team led by Carnegie's Robert Hazen predicts that Earth has more than 1,500 undiscovered minerals and that the exact mineral diversity of our planet is unique and could not be duplicated anywhere in the ...

4 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

laserdaveb
5 / 5 (2) May 12, 2009
breaks my heart though....charcoal grilled tastes sooooo much better!
ealex
3 / 5 (2) May 12, 2009
This article has changed my life.
I will never use charcoal to grill my meat ever again.

Thank you Physorg.
Thank you.
Modernmystic
4.2 / 5 (5) May 12, 2009
This is going right to the very front of my "I could care less" file...
laserdaveb
5 / 5 (1) May 12, 2009
your still gonna file it? at least wait till after dinner!

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.