Swedish court to issue verdict in Pirate Bay case

Apr 15, 2009 By MALIN RISING , Associated Press Writer
The Pirate Bay logo

(AP) -- Innovative digital pioneers or reckless cyber pirates? The founders of file-sharing hub The Pirate Bay are either heroes or villains depending on whom you ask.

On Friday a Stockholm court will rule on whether the four men broke Swedish copyright law by running and funding the Web site, which has become the entertainment industry's enemy No. 1 after successful court actions against file-swapping sites such as Grokster and Kazaa.

The provides a forum for its estimated 22 million users to freely download music, movies and computer games so-called torrent files - popular because they enable users share the parts they have already downloaded, increasing for the most sought-after files. But the site itself doesn't host any protected material, which is why defendants Gottfrid Svartholm Warg, Peter Sunde, Fredrik Neij, and Carl Lundstrom say they haven't done anything illegal.

Prosecutors charged them with accessory and conspiracy to break copyright law and asked the court to hand down one-year prison sentences to each. They also face 120 million kronor ($14.3 million) in compensation claims from Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc., MGM Pictures Inc., Colombia Pictures Industries Inc., 20th Century Fox Films Co., Sony BMG, Universal and EMI.

In keeping with The Pirate Bay's defiant attitude, Sunde told The Associated Press by telephone the site would keep running regardless of the verdict, and insisted he wouldn't give the entertainment companies a single krona in damages.

"I would rather burn that money than give it to them," he said.

Experts say the ruling is significant because a guilty verdict would raise questions about whether mainstream search engines like Google or YouTube can be held accountable for content downloaded illegally by its users. Andre Rickardsson, a computer expert and former investigator for the Swedish security police, said that, in essence, the only thing that separates Google from The Pirate Bay is their attitude.

"Google has a more humble and smarter approach than The Pirate Bay," Rickardsson said.

Google has a stated policy that says anyone can ask them to remove copyright-protected material. The Pirate Bay openly mocks such requests from record companies, publishing them on the site along with their own explicit responses.

The court hearings, which ended March 3, renewed debate about file-sharing in Sweden, where many defend the right to swap songs and movies freely on the Internet. Critics say that Swedish authorities caved in to pressure from the U.S. when they launched the crackdown on The Pirate Bay in 2006.

The Pirate Bay's supporters set up a Web site dedicated to the trial, and the defendants sent updates from the court hearings through social network Twitter.

Prosecutor Hakan Roswall rejected claims there isn't enough evidence to convict the defendants, saying the site provides three services that are essential for the users to be able to share files of copyright protected material.

The verdict Friday is likely to be appealed by the losing side. The judge could also decide to request advice from the European of Justice before making a decision.

©2009 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Explore further: Former federal agent pleads guilty to stealing bitcoins

Related Stories

Kazaa hit by file-sharing crackdown

Sep 06, 2005

Following in the footsteps of the U.S. courts, an Australian federal judge Monday ruled against the file-swapping network Kazaa for making it easier for Web users to download copyrighted music, but he denied allegations by ...

Google, music labels launch China download service

Mar 30, 2009

(AP) -- Google Inc. and major music companies launched a free Internet music download service for China on Monday in a bid to help turn a field dominated by pirates into a profitable, legitimate business.

Recommended for you

Former federal agent pleads guilty to stealing bitcoins

4 hours ago

A former undercover federal agent pleaded guilty to extortion and related charges after acknowledging he channeled more than $700,000 in digital currency from the Silk Road online drug bazaar he was investigating.

New approach to online compatibility

Jun 30, 2015

Many of the online social networks match users with each other based on common keywords and assumed shared interests based on their activity. A new approach that could help users find new friends and contacts with a greater ...

Most internet anonymity software leaks users' details

Jun 29, 2015

Virtual Private Networks (VPNs) are legal and increasingly popular for individuals wanting to circumvent censorship, avoid mass surveillance or access geographically limited services like Netflix and BBC ...

WikiLeaks says NSA spied on French business

Jun 29, 2015

WikiLeaks has released documents that it says show that the U.S. National Security Agency eavesdropped on France's top finance officials and high-stakes French export bids over a decade in what the group called targeted economic ...

User comments : 3

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Apr 15, 2009
Well, Pirate Bay is really more of a figure head than the problem itself, but I guess piracy is not something that can really be combated. It takes just one person uploading a torrent for others to download and start seeding it. the most popular torrents will always be well seeded. Still, I guess these companies can make some of the money they thought they lost back through law suits. I doubt their actual losses are anywhere near what they claim, though. They likely counted each download as a sale. But, I bet pirates are largely cheapskates. I mean, who in their right mind would pay to see a Jim Carry movie? If people could see it for free however, it may be worth downloading. If anyone is losing business to these people, it is Netflix. Basically the same idea as downloading as many movies as you want, but they at least charge a monthly fee.
not rated yet Apr 16, 2009
Yes Man was not even worth downloading. ;)

I've got a good feeling about this.

"Google has a more humble and smarter approach than The Pirate Bay"

Whatever. The law is the law, if one is guilty so is the other, you can't hold them to different standards because of their "attitude." (In a perfect world. I'm sure may try.)

David v. Goliath
not rated yet Apr 16, 2009
Yes Man was not even worth downloading. ;)

I've got a good feeling about this.

"Google has a more humble and smarter approach than The Pirate Bay"

Whatever. The law is the law, if one is guilty so is the other, you can't hold them to different standards because of their "attitude." (In a perfect world. I'm sure may try.)

David v. Goliath

Agreed, you cant bring one down without the other based on there attitude. But Google is an american company, wonder would they take action? They pressure the EU, we should Pressure them!

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.