Is one diet as good as another? New study says no and tells you why

March 4, 2009

Any diet will do? Not if you want to lose fat instead of muscle. Not if you want to lower your triglyceride levels so you'll be less likely to develop diabetes and heart disease. Not if you want to avoid cravings that tempt you to cheat on your diet. And not if you want to keep the weight off long-term.

"Our latest study shows you have a better chance of achieving all these goals if you follow a diet that is moderately high in protein," said Donald Layman, a University of Illinois professor emeritus of nutrition. The research was published in the March Journal of Nutrition.

Layman's new study followed the weight-loss efforts of 130 persons at two sites, the U of I and Penn State University, during 4 months of active weight loss and 8 months of maintenance.

Two previous studies had looked at short-term weight loss; this one was designed to look at long-term effects, he said.

Although both plans were equal in calories, half the group followed a moderate-protein diet (40% carbohydrates, 30% protein, 30% fat) while the other followed a diet based on USDA's food-guide pyramid (55% carbohydrates, 15% protein, 15% fat).

"Persons in the first group ate twice the amount of protein as the second group," said Layman.

And the difference in protein made all the difference in improved body composition and body lipids, he said.

Although the amount of weight lost in both groups was similar, at 4 months participants in the protein group had lost 22 percent more body fat than members of the food-pyramid group. At 12 months, the moderate-protein dieters had lost 38 percent more body fat.

"The additional protein helped dieters preserve muscle. That's important for long-term weight loss because muscle burns calories—if you lose muscle, and you used to be able to consume 2,000 calories without gaining weight, you'll find that now you can only eat, say, 1,800 calories without weight gain," he said.

What were the effects on lipids? Although at 4 months the food-guide pyramid appeared to be more effective in lowering LDL and total cholesterol levels, at 12 months LDL levels came back up until both diets were equally effective, Layman said.

"This is the first study to show that short-term changes in LDL cholesterol are not maintained with long-term weight loss. Most scientists believe that high cholesterol is more a factor of genetics than of diet," he said.

But the moderate-protein diet had by far the bigger effect on lowering triglycerides, and that lasted as long as individuals remained on the diet, he said.

"Of the two types of lipid problems, high triglycerides pose a greater risk for heart disease. Approximately twice as many people have high triglycerides, and people with this condition are approximately four times more likely to die from heart disease," the scientist said.

To ensure compliance, participants met every week for weigh-ins and nutrition instruction. "We taught participants how to follow their diet, how to grocery shop, and how to prepare the meals. They also measured everything they ate three days a week," he said.

"Studies that report there is no difference among diets also report that subjects were not carefully following the diets," said Layman. "It's very important to realize the difference between diet compliance and diet effectiveness."

The protein diet was easier to follow and maintain long-term, with 64 percent of the moderate-protein dieters completing the study compared to 45 percent of dieters using the high-carbohydrate diet, Layman said.

"Subjects on the moderate-protein diet reported that they weren't as interested in snacks or desserts, and they didn't have food cravings. When you eat protein, you feel full longer," he said.

Average weight loss for the protein group was 23 percent higher than the food-pyramid group, with 31 percent of "completers" in the protein group losing more of than 10 percent of their initial body weight versus 21 percent of the food-pyramid group.

Source: University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign

Explore further: An orange a day keeps scurvy away

Related Stories

An orange a day keeps scurvy away

August 3, 2015

Centuries ago, ships often sailed with crews numbering in the hundreds returning with tens. Cause of death: Scurvy - a severe depletion of Vitamin C. Today's explorers cross miles of space with no hope of finding an island ...

I sprint for exercise: NASA's iRAT study

May 19, 2015

Run far or run fast? That is one of the questions NASA is trying to answer with one of its latest studies—and the answers may help keep us in shape on Earth, as well as in space. Even with regular exercise, astronauts who ...

The truth about the war on wheat

October 3, 2014

If you believe the best-seller lists, the biggest bad in the supermarket aisles is not fat or sodium or sugar, but wheat. We have been warned that eating wheat makes our bellies fatter and triggers diseases ranging from diabetes ...

Recommended for you

How the finch changes its tune

August 3, 2015

Like top musicians, songbirds train from a young age to weed out errors and trim variability from their songs, ultimately becoming consistent and reliable performers. But as with human musicians, even the best are not machines. ...

Machine Translates Thoughts into Speech in Real Time

December 21, 2009

( -- By implanting an electrode into the brain of a person with locked-in syndrome, scientists have demonstrated how to wirelessly transmit neural signals to a speech synthesizer. The "thought-to-speech" process ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Mar 04, 2009
There is no objective study which supports the high carbohydrate level recommended by the USDA.

not rated yet Mar 05, 2009
JerryPark, you are referring to the 40% figure? I don't know what it's based on, but the 40/30/30 works wonders for all the high output swimming, biking, rock climbing, and weight lifting I do. Depending on the workout I will switch to more protein, less carbs... but for moderate output activities, like biking, the 40% seems to work well throughout the day.

My 2 cents. :)
not rated yet Mar 05, 2009
I've recently switched to a diet with lots of nuts, fruit, vegetables, fish, tofu, some chicken, and red meat once each week to 2 weeks. I have lost most of my body fat and my training and high intensity martial arts training has improved significantly. Because I eat a lot of nuts, the protein and good fats in my diet are very high. By following such a diet I have lost 5% body weight, and my muscle strength and endurance has increased. I barely have any fat on my body, and abs are easily visible. The way I found out about the scientific fundaments of diet was after reading Ray Kurzweil's book named Fantastic Voyage. My diet is slightly different to what would be considered optimal in the book, this is because I eat lots of nuts. In finishing, diet of whole foods, good fats, and last of all LOW GI is really good for your health and welbeing.
5 / 5 (1) Mar 05, 2009
The numbers quoted for the USDA's food-guide pyramid (55% carbohydrates, 15% protein, 15% fat) do not add up. What are the correct percentages?
not rated yet Mar 08, 2009

I was just referring to high carbohydrate recommendations is general. The USDA recommends at least 50% of calories from carbohydrates and the ADA even recommends high carbohydrate diets for people with diabetes.

Of the three components of the human diet (fats, proteins and carbohydrates), carbohydrates are the only non-essential component and the one which is always touted as the most essential.
not rated yet Mar 08, 2009
The dieting business is just that - a business and all diets are products to be sold to the gullible. Good balanced diet and exercise is all that´s required - there are no magic products, except in the marketin plans of those in the business

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.