The pluses and (mostly) minuses of biofuels

February 23, 2009 By Robert Sanders
Cornfield waste, or stover; perennials grown on marginal land; or municipal waste, ranging from kitchen scraps to cardboard, could be used as feedstocks to produce ethanol using cellulosic technology.

Speakers at last week’s AAAS meeting presented abundant evidence that tropical rainforest destruction has accelerated in recent years, at least in part because of the worldwide push to produce more biofuels.

As Europe and America rush to supplant polluting fossil fuels with plant-derived fuels like ethanol, soy and palm oil, farmers in the tropics are accelerating forest clearing to plant more sugarcane, soybeans and palm trees to meet the demand. What should be carbon-neutral biofuels - the carbon dioxide these plants take in while growing is returned to the atmosphere when they're burned, resulting in zero net carbon release - end up spewing more CO2 into the atmosphere as forests are slashed and burned.

Carbon dioxide is such a potent greenhouse gas that one recent study estimated it will take hundreds of years to recoup the greenhouse gas damage of clearing rainforests to grow and harvest plants for biofuels.

In one session, Michael Coe of Woods Hole Research Center in Massachusetts illustrated one ripple effect from the stampede to create more ethanol from corn in the United States. As corn prices skyrocketed several years ago, soybean fields were converted to corn, and the price of soy rose. As a result, farmers in Brazil, one of the main countries with the soil, climate and infrastructure to make up the difference, began to bulldoze rainforest to grow more soybeans.

"If reduced U.S. soybean production results in a parallel increase in Brazilian soybean production, a potential net release of 1,800 to 9,100 Tg (trillion grams) of CO2-equivalents of greenhouse gas emissions due to land-use change is possible," Coe wrote in a summary of his talk. That is equivalent to more than 9 billion metric tons of carbon dioxide.

Bulldozing Indonesian rainforests to plant oil palms

In the same session, Holly Gibbs of Stanford University reported that, despite assurances by biofuel producers that biofuel crops are being grown on degraded or already cleared lands, forest clearing throughout the tropics has increased. In Indonesia and Malaysia, especially, deforestation has accelerated as farmers scramble to plant oil palms to supply Europe with biodiesel fuel.

While growing crops on degraded land "would be restoring the land to a higher potential to provide environmental services for people," she said, "if biofuels are grown in place of forests, we're actually going to end up emitting a huge amount of carbon."

In the face of these reports that biofuels are worsening global warming, Dan Kammen, a UC Berkeley professor of energy and resources and director of the Renewable and Alternative Energy Laboratory, tried in a Feb. 14 session to put biofuels into perspective.

"No matter what people say about the good or bad aspects of a given fuel, whether it's oil, tar sands, biofuels, solar or wind, the fact is, a large number of these will be used for economic reasons, based on subsidies, momentum, vested interests, whatever," he said in his talk, "A Hunger for Power: The Global Nexus of Energy and Food." The key, he said, is to design global models that will guide policy makers in making the right choices.

The country has to develop models that allow us to assess "biofuel demand from a global perspective. You can't just look at it in terms of what happens on a hectare of land in Iowa, but also in terms of the conflicts between food, fiber, fuel and nature," Kammen said.

With regard to biofuels, Kammen was in agreement with the scientists reporting the negative aspects of biofuels in use today.

From a global perspective, he said, it’s clear that “if we pursue the path we are on, it is an environmental and food security loser.” Based on a soon-to-be-published study by Kammen and colleagues at Purdue University, no matter how sustainably the United States grows corn for ethanol, it will have a negative impact on greenhouse gases because of the growth of soy in tropics.

Leading the way to cellulosic

Research programs like UC Berkeley and LBNL's Energy Biosciences Institute, funded last year by oil giant BP to the tune of $500 million over 10 years, are developing such models at the same time as they are pursuing next-generation biofuels. Cellulosic biofuels, made by more complete fermentation of biofuel feedstocks, won’t be commercially viable for 5-10 years, but they and other technologies, including algae, are attractive options that together may combine to produce as much as 10 percent of the nation’s energy needs, he said.

“None is a home run individually, but if together they could be done sustainably, they are big enough opportunities that there will be strong economic forces to develop a range of them,” said Kammen.

He held up California as an example of what the nation and the world can do to reduce greenhouse gas emissions using biofuels as one part of a broad “energy portfolio.” The state's AB 32, passed in 2006, presents a framework for reducing carbon emissions, with the 2020 goal of returning California emissions to what they were in 1990, which would amount to slightly more than a 25 percent reduction from current emissions.

More importantly, a 2005 executive order by Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger established the goal of reducing carbon emissions 80 percent by 2050, which is the number that "those of us who work with the IPCC (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change) have effectively endorsed, not as a solution to global warming, but as the best soft landing; the beginning of what we want to get to," Kammen said.

Combined with California's low carbon fuel standard, which addresses carbon emissions from vehicles, and the state's developing renewable energy portfolio, which mandates that 33 percent of the state’s electricity come from zero-carbon sources by 2020, California has created a model for the nation. In fact, he said, “a version of California's plan, scaled up to the size of the nation, is Obama's evolving federal plan - the endpoint numbers are about the same, though the paths are not yet set."

While Kammen admitted that he expects biofuels to be replaced by better and sustainable sources of energy within 50 years, for now they will remain part of a portfolio that will include solar and wind as well as coal, oil and nuclear power.

“We, as a nation, need to use what is happening in the U.S. West and in California as an example of the context in which biofuels are being explored,” said Kammen.

Provided by UC Berkeley

Explore further: EU on track to meet 2020 target for renewable energy: report

Related Stories

Australia needs a strong carbon price to meet Paris target

November 30, 2016

Australia needs to consider a carbon price of around $US140 a tonne by 2040 to help the world meet its target to keep global warming below 2 degrees Celsius, experts have told The Australian National University annual Energy ...

EU unveils plans to boost 'clean energy' use

November 30, 2016

The EU on Wednesday unveiled "clean energy" plans to boost renewable use, cut waste and reduce subsidies for coal power in a bid to meet its commitments to the Paris climate deal.

Expect Trump to gut environmental regulations: expert

November 29, 2016

If a Trump administration follows his campaign rhetoric and advisers, then his most immediate and far-reaching environmental target will be domestic and international efforts to address climate change.

Recommended for you

Swiss unveil stratospheric solar plane

December 7, 2016

Just months after two Swiss pilots completed a historic round-the-world trip in a Sun-powered plane, another Swiss adventurer on Wednesday unveiled a solar plane aimed at reaching the stratosphere.

Solar panels repay their energy 'debt': study

December 6, 2016

The climate-friendly electricity generated by solar panels in the past 40 years has all but cancelled out the polluting energy used to produce them, a study said Tuesday.

Wall-jumping robot is most vertically agile ever built

December 6, 2016

Roboticists at UC Berkeley have designed a small robot that can leap into the air and then spring off a wall, or perform multiple vertical jumps in a row, resulting in the highest robotic vertical jumping agility ever recorded. ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Feb 23, 2009
What is needed is economic incentives for countries to preserve their rainforests, backed by penalties for allowing destruction by any means, including illegal logging.
not rated yet Feb 23, 2009
The palm oil industry is guilty of some truly heinous ecological atrocities, including the systematic genocide of orangutans. The forests of Borneo and Sumatra are the only place where these gentle, intelligent creatures live, and the cultivation of palm oil has directly led to the brutal deaths of thousands of individuals as the industry has expanded into undisturbed areas of rainforest.

When the forest is cleared, adult orangutans are typically shot on sight. These peaceful, sentient beings are beaten, burned, mutilated, tortured and often eaten. Babies are torn off their dying mothers so they can be sold on the black market as illegal pets to wealthy families who see them as status symbols of their own power and prestige. I am not trying to be overly dramatic. This actually happens. It has been documented time and again.

Some of the luckier orangutans are confiscated and brought to sanctuaries such as the Nyaru Menteng Orangutan Rescue Center, which is now home to nearly 700 orphaned and displaced orangutans in Central Kalimantan (Indonesian Borneo). Many of these orangutans are only several weeks old when they arrive, and all of them are psychologically traumatized and desperate for their mothers-- who are no longer alive.

Nyaru Menteng is managed by a remarkable woman named Lone Droscher Nielsen and is featured on Animal Planet's series 'Orangutan Island'.

To learn more about the crisis facing wild orangutans and see how you can help protect them, please visit the Orangutan Outreach website:

Thank you for taking the time to read my long comment!

Best wishes,

Richard Zimmerman
Director, Orangutan Outreach
Reach out and save the orangutans!
Join our Facebook Cause:
not rated yet Feb 24, 2009
Kammen's flaw is that he wants to plan out glogal agriculture from the top down. Central planning rarely works well on a large scale - its neither quick enough to respond to changes nor flexible enough to meet the needs of the growers.
not rated yet Feb 24, 2009
Central planning rarely works well on a large scale...
Depends on what you mean by "Central Planning". If detailed five-year plans at the individual field level, then agreed. HOWEVER, in a market economy, SOME centrally issued rules must exist, else neither a market or an economy can exist.

Trick is finding a near-ideal balance.
not rated yet Feb 25, 2009
I was thinking of the diverging interests of the farmer who wants to maximize his short and long term yields vs the "macro planner" who's interests are guided by some long term goal that is in the planner's interest but not necessarily in the farmer's interest. Its assumed that the individual farmer best understands what is most efficient and effective for his unique situation. Individuals, groups, businesses, governments - all act in their own perceived best interest, and the interests of one isn't necessarily the interests of all. Thus I don't see central planning as having the individual growers' interests in mind. Given that, failure seems likely on either end of that dynamic.
1 / 5 (1) Feb 28, 2009
I have one idea how deforestation could perhaps be slowed down somewhat.

The solution I am thinking about is to establish a program of ownership of rain forests. The areas which are most at risk of deforestation should be divided into plots and auctioned to international community. The titles to the land would not grant the right to modify the land but the owner would gain the title of protector of the land he bought. A tax should also be associated with such ownership with the money going to the local people, this tax should be high enough to give them incentive to protect the land and a feeling that they also benefit from the deal.

The owner would of course be allowed to sell or abandon his right if he would choose to.

The whole purpose of this program is to give wealthy and environmentally conscious individuals or organizations a way in which they can help protect the forests. Right now they can donate the money to some cause but the effect is much less direct and in most cases they have no real knowledge what the money will be spent on. Here on the other hand they would know precisely what plot of land they help protect, they would have the title to this land, would be able to come visit it, they would also know they help local population, etc. They could really see that they are making the difference.

On the other hand money from auctions and taxes would help local community and give it an incentive to protect the forest, it would give the forest a monetary value and an owner who could care for it.
not rated yet Mar 09, 2009
Superhuman, that is an awful, awful idea. Its almost like buying a time share you aren't allowed to use at all, except worse.

It has all the negatives of land ownership (taxes, liability for what happens on it) without any of the benefits (use of the land and its resources as you see fit).

Why not follow the existing models for land protection already in use:

Government level: state forests, state parks, wilderness conservation areas, wildlife management areas.

corporate level: land trusts

Private level: what I call the Robert Redford model (a private citizen buys up a couple thousand acres of land and doesn't develop it).

Any of these models would be preferable to what you suggest, as these all respect property rights.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.