# A new kind of counting: Scientists develop computer algorithm to solve previously unsolvable counting problems

##### Feb 11, 2009

(PhysOrg.com) -- How many different sudokus are there? How many different ways are there to color in the countries on a map? And how do atoms behave in a solid? Researchers at the Max Planck Institute for Dynamics and Self-Organization in Göttingen and at Cornell University (Ithaca, USA) have now developed a new method that quickly provides an answer to these questions.

In principle, there has always been a way to solve them. However, computers were unable to find the solution as the calculations took too long. With the new method, the scientists look at separate sections of the problem and work through them one at a time. Up to now, each stage of the calculation has involved the whole map or the whole sudoku. The answers to many problems in physics, mathematics and computer science can be provided in this way for the first time. (New Journal of Physics, February 4, 2009)

Whether sudoku, a map of Germany or solid bodies - in all of these cases, it’s all about counting possibilities. In the sudoku, it is the permitted solutions; in the solid body, it is the possible arrangements of atoms. In the map, the question is how many ways the map can be colored so that adjacent countries are always shown in a different color. Scientists depict these counting problems as a network of lines and nodes. Consequently, they need to answer just one question: How many different ways are there to color in the nodes with a certain number of colors? The only condition: nodes joined by a line may not have the same color. Depending on the application, the color of a node is given a completely new significance. In the case of the map, "color" actually means color; with sudoku the "colors" represent different figures.

"The existing algorithm copies the whole network for each stage of the calculation and only changes one aspect of it each time," explains Frank van Bussel of the Max Planck Institute for Dynamics and Self-Organization (MPIDS). Increasing the number of nodes dramatically increases the calculation time. For a square lattice the size of a chess board, this is estimated to be many billions of years. The new algorithm developed by the Göttingen-based scientists is significantly faster. "Our calculation for the chess board lattice only takes seven seconds," explains Denny Fliegner from MPIDS.

This is how it’s done: With the new method, the researchers move through the network node by node. As if the computer program were short-sighted, it only ever looks at the next node point and not at the whole network. At the first node point, it cannot finalize the color selection as it would have to know how all the other nodes are connected to each other. However, instead of answering this question, the program notes down a formula for the first lattice point which contains this uncertainty as an unknown quantity. As it progresses through the network, all the connections become visible and the unknown quantities are eliminated. Having arrived at the final node point, the program’s knowledge of the network is complete.

This new method can be used on much more complicated cases than the existing standard algorithm. "We can now answer many questions in physics, graph theory and computer science that have hitherto been practically unsolvable," says Marc Timme from MPIDS. "For example, our method can be applied to antiferromagnetic solids," he adds. In these solid bodies, every atom has an internal rotational pulse, called spin, which can have different values. Usually, adjacent atoms exhibit different spins. It is now possible to calculate the number of possible spin arrangements, which will allow physicists to draw conclusions about the fundamental characteristics of the thermodynamics of solid bodies.

More information: Marc Timme, Frank van Bussel, Denny Fliegner, and Sebastian Stolzenberg, Counting Complex Disordered States by Effiecient Pattern Matching: Chromatic Polynomials and Potts Partition Functions, New Journal of Physics 11 (2009), 023001, February 4th, 2009, www.iop.org/EJ/abstract/1367-2630/11/2/023001/

Provided by Max-Planck-Institute

Explore further: The legacy of John Nash and his equilibrium theory

## Related Stories

#### Harvesting usable fuel from nuclear waste – and dealing with the last chemical troublemakers

5 minutes ago

Nuclear energy provides about 11% of the world's total electricity today. This power source produces no carbon dioxide during plant operation, meaning it doesn't contribute to climate change via greenhouse gas ...

#### Impact crater or supervolcano caldera?

10 minutes ago

At first glance, the region covered by this latest Mars Express image release appears to be pockmarked with impact craters. But the largest structure among them may hold a rather explosive secret: it could ...

#### New 'deep learning' technique enables robot mastery of skills via trial and error

11 minutes ago

UC Berkeley researchers have developed algorithms that enable robots to learn motor tasks through trial and error using a process that more closely approximates the way humans learn, marking a major milestone ...

#### Contaminated green waste has 'catastrophic' implications for historic environment

11 minutes ago

Archaeologists are calling for better regulation of the control and use of green waste in order to protect the historic environment. Research carried out at Newcastle University has highlighted that the level of metallic conta ...

#### Field study shows how a GM crop can have diminishing success at fighting off insect pest

11 minutes ago

A new study from North Carolina State University and Clemson University finds that the toxin in a widely used genetically modified (GM) crop is having little impact on the crop pest called corn earworm (Helicoverpa ...

#### Agricultural standards can do more to mitigate risk in commodity production

13 minutes ago

Standards designed to improve sustainability of production of agricultural commodities could do more to help address root causes of water-related risk, according to a new WWF report.

## Recommended for you

#### Notre Dame paper examines how students understand mathematics

9 hours ago

It's both the bane of many parents and what has been called a major national vulnerability: the inability of many children to understand mathematics. Understanding that problem and developing strategies to overcome it is ...

#### Girls receive conflicting career messages from media, new research shows

9 hours ago

Teenage girls like and feel more similar to women in appearance-focused jobs such as models and actresses, though they find female CEOs and military pilots to be better role models, according to a new study ...

#### Paleontologists pioneer laser-beam scanning of dinosaur fossils

9 hours ago

A team of scientists based largely at the University of Kansas and the Burke Museum of Natural History and Culture in Washington has developed methods of using commercial-grade laser equipment to find and ...

#### Lethal wounds on skull may indicate 430,000-year-old murder

15 hours ago

Lethal wounds identified on a human skull in the Sima de los Huesos, Spain, may indicate one of the first cases of murder in human history, some 430,000 years ago, according to a study published May 27 2015 ...

#### New human ancestor species from Ethiopia lived alongside Lucy's species

16 hours ago

A new relative joins "Lucy" on the human family tree. An international team of scientists, led by Dr. Yohannes Haile-Selassie of The Cleveland Museum of Natural History, has discovered a 3.3 to 3.5 million-year-old ...

#### Using debt to maintain status quo leaves families on rocky road to recovery

16 hours ago

Economically vulnerable families are increasingly willing to take on debt to maintain a basic standard of living—a situation that can put them into a deep financial hole, according to a new University of Michigan study.

##### vivcollins
not rated yet Feb 11, 2009
How long before this hits CFD I wonder
##### magpies
2.3 / 5 (3) Feb 11, 2009
Why is this new?
##### Husky
not rated yet Feb 11, 2009
A new word for the dictionary: quantumchromomathematics ?
not rated yet Feb 11, 2009
Ah the world of dynamic programming. If we can't solve problem A, but can solve problem B, just find a way to map B to A.

Trading storage for speed is a viable option now that memory is cheap.
##### h0dges
3.3 / 5 (3) Feb 11, 2009
Exciting stuff.
##### Soylent
not rated yet Feb 12, 2009
Trading storage for speed is a viable option now that memory is cheap.

Doesn't always work well; memory grows ever more distant from the processor(with the exception of integrated memory controllers).

When you're doing something that defeats the usual tricks of caching, out of order execution, speculative reads etc. (like pointer chasing or something) it's going to take upwards of 100-200 clock cycles to get the requested piece of data and you could have executed a lot of instructions in that time.
##### KBK
not rated yet Feb 12, 2009
It also presents a new methodological attack scenario for security encryption breach programming, ie the breaking of previously 'secure code'.

256 bit? Not good enough........

That's the way the essence of 'reality' tends to be. You can't have one side of the coin-without the other. Both situations emerge, relatively speaking-at the same time.

Sorry. That's the way she goes...
##### mogmich
not rated yet Feb 12, 2009
Maybe uncertainty in nature (Quantum Mechanics) is there for the same reason: in order to make an otherwise impossible calculation possible?
##### Damon_Hastings
not rated yet Feb 12, 2009
I am a computer programmer, and I am befuddled by this. How is this algorithm new? The description of the algorithm is fairly vague here -- the phrase "notes down a formula" is especially frustrating. Computers don't generally note down entire "formulas", so it's anyone's guess what this actually means.

I don't see any explanation of how this new algorithm differs from the standard backtracking (node-by-node) algorithm which was given in my computer science textbook in college 20 years ago, and which does *not* copy the entire matrix at each step, and which was quite slow anyway. Could the author of this article please explain the difference? The article refers to "looking at separate sections of the problem" which sounds tantalizingly like parallelization (which would indeed be a real improvement) -- but then goes on to describe what sounds like a standard backtracking algorithm with no parallelization.

The standard backtracking algorithm is listed as the first result from a google search on "map coloring backtracking algorithm". (Okay, well, that implementation does copy the entire matrix each time, but it would be rather trivial to add in an "undo" stack to allow undoing modifications which were made directly to the original matrix rather than a copy. They only left that optimization out of this example for simplicity, since this is a teaching manual for an introductory programming class.)
##### BeastOfBodmin
not rated yet Feb 15, 2009
From magpie:
> Why is this new?

From Damon_Hastings:
> I don't see any explanation of how this new algorithm differs from the standard backtracking ...

Have you read the actual paper linked to at the bottom of the article?
##### Damon_Hastings
5 / 5 (1) Feb 16, 2009
From Damon_Hastings:
> I don't see any explanation of how this new algorithm differs from the standard backtracking ...

Have you read the actual paper linked to at the bottom of the article?

That article is not written for even a well-educated computer programmer. It dives quickly and deeply into quantum mechanics, of all things. The "zero-temperature partition function of the Potts antiferromagnet" (whatever that is) seems to be the key to the whole thing.

To understand the dense, narrow-niche jargon would require several years of training in QM and apparently a few exotic fields of math, as well. But I don't really need a deep understanding anyway, just a basic overview. For that, a more efficient way to get a basic overview would be to just call the author and interview him. And then maybe I could summarize my basic overview into an article which I could publish on, oh, I don't know, maybe some popular science news website where others could benefit from my work without having to call the author themselves.

Personally, I don't think I should have to take a course in quantum mechanics to understand a new computer algorithm on map-coloring. But I don't know, maybe the author decided that no one without a QM degree could even understand a basic overview of this new algorithm, and that's why he left it out and instead gave a basic overview of *all* backtracking map-coloring algorithms.
##### paulcurran
not rated yet May 10, 2009
The Potts antiferromagnet is equivalent to the chromatic polynomial. The chromatic polynomial is a polynomial of a graph which counts the number of distinct ways it can be colored. Colorings are counted as distinct even they differ only by permutation of colors.

I read the article and while hard at times I was able to follow it. Granted I had some courses in QM, but that was over 20 years ago.

If this type of material is to become critical one day for programmers, one really doesn't need to study quantum mechanics. However I can see where studying the methods of QM would be very advantageous. But at one time calculus was seen as a rather esoteric topic but it is now seen as a topic that many need to know. Perhaps one day the mathematics of QM would be seen in the same light.