'Buy local' not the answer to smaller carbon footprint, professor argues

Dec 17, 2008 By Geoff Thomas

(PhysOrg.com) -- In 2006, certain cafeterias on U of T’s St. George campus began serving meals made from ingredients grown mostly in Ontario – an initiative undertaken with Local Food Plus, an organization that promotes local farmers, and campaigns to reduce Canada’s carbon footprint. But at U of T Mississauga, no such food partnership exists – and that may not be a bad thing, according to Professor Pierre Desrochers of geography.

As he argues in a recent policy paper (Yes, We Have No Bananas: A Critique of the ‘Food Miles’ Perspective), a New Zealand apple eaten in Spiegel Hall has more “food miles” (distance food has travelled from production to consumption) on it than the indigenous McIntosh, but its production may have resulted in fewer greenhouse gases. New Zealand apples, he explains, are grown during our winter months and do not need to spend long periods of time in cold storage facilities.

Desrochers’ paper challenges the recent popularity of movements like the 100-mile diet and has made him a virtual pariah to the anti-Agri Business brigade. “The people who protest my paper circle together like musk oxen. They’re reluctant to debate or consider the data. They’re angry at corporations, but feel powerless to effect change. So they transpose their efforts to something they can relate to: food purchases.”

According to Desrochers, buying locally grown but economically uncompetitive products almost never reduces greenhouse gases. In the U.S., more than 80% of food-related energy consumption comes from food production, while the transportation segment accounts for less than 10%. Western European consumers would actually reduce their greenhouse gas emissions if they bought milk solids or apples from highly efficient New Zealand producers rather than from highly subsidized and much less efficient local producers.

“Long distance food transportation by highly efficient diesel container ships represents only a tiny percentage of total energy expenditure in agricultural production,” he says. “Cold storage or greenhouses have much more significant expenditures. North Americans somehow forget that we have seasons!”

Desrochers is not against local food production. He says it works in some places, especially in season. But there was a reason our ancestors shifted away from subsistence farming. “Our modern food supply chain is a demonstrably superior alternative that has evolved through constant competition and ever more rigorous management efficiency.”

Desrochers has no illusions of winning over the prevailing (and politically correct) Local Food Plus faction that pronounces: Let’s go the distance so our food won’t have to. “My brother is a Quebec politician who represents an agricultural riding. I don’t know if I can ever convince him that not buying from local producers is the right thing to do!”

Provided by University of Toronto Mississauga

Explore further: Long lists are eroding the value of being a scientific author

Related Stories

Production of broccoli on East Coast proves viable

May 20, 2015

Picked by hand on West Coast farms, chilled to 32 degrees within five hours and packed on ice for a road trip east, broccoli is a finicky crop to provide fresh to East Coast consumers.

New way to save fish—and fishers

May 19, 2015

An end to poaching will benefit ocean conservation and fishing communities worldwide, an Australian-led scientific study shows.

Bodyguards for precious seeds—without chemical mace

May 19, 2015

Naturally occurring, plant-associated bacteria as a crop protection agent are now avail-able for use in crop protection to alleviate the contamination of soil with pesticides—arguably the most environmentally ...

Atmospheric release of BPA may reach nearby waterways

May 19, 2015

Water contamination by hormone-disrupting pollutants is threatening water quality around the world. Existing research has determined that harmful concentrations of Bisphenol-A (BPA), a chemical used in consumer ...

JRC thematic report: Science for food

May 13, 2015

The JRC has released a new report on its scientific support to EU's "from farm to fork" policy which ensures Europeans enjoy safe and nutritious food, while facilitating the food industry to work under the best possible conditions. ...

Recommended for you

Top UK scientists warn against EU exit

May 22, 2015

A group of leading British scientists including Nobel-winning geneticist Paul Nurse warned leaving the European Union could threaten research funding, in a letter published in The Times newspaper on Friday.

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

AnneMac
not rated yet Dec 18, 2008
Professor Desrochers is right that local alone is not the whole story. That is why the University of Toronto is working with Local Food Plus (LFP). The foundation stone of the LFP program is local AND sustainable food production; that's the "plus" in Local Food Plus. All LFP certified farmers and processors are from Ontario. They have also met standards that require them to employ sustainable production systems that reduce reliance on synthetic pesticides (which are produced from fossil fuels) and conserve soil and water, to provide safe and fair working conditions for on-farm labour, to provide healthy and humane care for livestock, to protect and enhance wildlife habitat and biodiversity on working farm landscapes, and to reduce on-farm energy consumption. Local sustainable food production addresses greenhouse gas emissions associated with both transportation and the production system. As well, local sustainable food supports a vibrant food culture, rural revitalization, and protection of native species. In other words, when "local" is combined with "sustainable", as it is in LFP certification, it means much more than a calculation of the kilometres that food has travelled from farm to fork.

-- Anne Macdonald, U of T St. George campus, and Lori Stahlbrand, President, Local Food Plus

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.