Actions speak louder: Why we use our past behavior to determine our current attitudes

Nov 12, 2007

Sometimes it’s difficult for us to remember how we felt about a product. Was that restaurant pretty good or just okay? Was the movie boring or enjoyable?

A new study reveals that, in many of these cases, consumers will use postpurchase actions – and advertising – as a proxy for lost memories, even if these actions are not a good indication of how we actually felt while using the product. In other words, if we gab about a terrible dinner and a boring movie with loved ones, we might mistake the positive memory of talking about the experience for positive memories of the experience itself.

“People use their feelings of liking or disliking elicited during prior experiences to guide decisions about their future,” explains Elizabeth Cowley (University of Sydney). “When reflecting back on prior events, people assume that their behavior was consistent with the feelings they held at the time.”

For example, Cowley had participants view a short excerpt of a film. She then exposed one group to advertisements for the film containing humorous dialogue, asking them to rate the entertainment value of the advertisement. The other group was exposed to facts about the film and asked to rate the informational value. Participants were then asked to make a choice between the film just sampled and three other film clips. Cowley shows that post-experience exposure to a task requiring emotional judgment interfered with the participants’ ability to remember how well they initially liked the clip, while tasks involving unemotional judgments did not interfere.

“When interference reduces the ability to retrieve experience-based feelings, consumers may unconsciously reflect on what they did to infer how they felt because their post-experience behavior is more accessible,” Cowley writes. “The study showed that people are not particularly adept at retrieving their experience-based affective reaction when they have other non-experience based reactions in memory.”

She continues: “Perhaps the behavioral information may have ‘felt right’ because of an implicit [belief] that behaviors are consistent with attitudes.”

Citation: Elizabeth Cowley, “How Enjoyable Was It" Remembering an Affective Reaction to a Previous Consumption Experience.” Journal of Consumer Research: December 2007.

Source: University of Chicago

Explore further: The new normal? Addressing gun violence in America

Related Stories

Blueprint for a thirsty world from Down Under

22 minutes ago

The Millennium Drought in southeastern Australia forced Greater Melbourne, a city of 4.3 million people, to successfully implement innovations that hold critical lessons for water-stressed regions around the world, according ...

Recommended for you

The new normal? Addressing gun violence in America

9 hours ago

Article Spotlight features summaries written in collaboration with authors of recently published articles by the Journals Program of the American Psychological Association. The articles are nominated by the editors as noteworthy ...

Demi Lovato gets vocal about mental illness

12 hours ago

(HealthDay)—Demi Lovato huddled in the back of her tour bus, eyes wet with tears as she watched a horde of fans streaming into the venue where she was about to play.

Acquiring 'perfect' pitch may be possible for some adults

13 hours ago

If you're a musician, this sounds too good to be true: University of Chicago psychologists have been able to train some adults to develop the prized musical ability of absolute pitch, and the training's effects ...

How men and women see each other when online dating

15 hours ago

In the world of online dating, nothing is as it seems. But that doesn't stop many of us from leaping to the wrong conclusions about people. A recent paper presented at the Annual Conference of the International ...

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

HarryStottle
not rated yet Nov 27, 2007
this suggests we can expect a new genre of "post consumption" advertising designed to make you believe you enjoyed the product more than you actually did. The aim will be to make it more likely that you speak favourably of the product to others who haven't yet sampled it...

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.